Bank leaves care home owner carrying Forex losses

MELBOURNE: The owner of a care home business is suing to recover $4.8 million lost when City Credit Capital allegedly sunk his deposits into “inappropriate” foreign exchange trades despite knowing he was an inexperienced investor.

John Dupuis argues that City Credit Capital (UK) overlooked his lack of trading experience and did not explain the risks involved when they began making foreign exchange bets on his behalf, according to recently public court documents filed at the High Court.  

The lawsuit claims that had Dupuis — who runs a nursing home business — been provided with information “that was clear, fair and nonmisleading as to the operation and performance of the account” or with details of the risks that he was exposed to, he would have closed the account immediately “and thereby avoided the losses which subsequently occurred.”

Dupuis claims he lost a total of $4.85 million between 2014 and 2015 and was induced to keep his account open by a series of “misrepresentations” about the performance of his investments and advice that went “beyond the mere provisions” by his account manager, the suit says.

Dupuis alleges that he was introduced to City Credit through a Chilean company while traveling around the country in early 2014. When applying for an account Dupuis inadvertently ticked a box indicating that his previous trading experience meant he could assess the risks involved in foreign exchange investments, the May 27 particulars of claim says.

This was at odds with other details on the form in which Dupuis indicated that he had no experience of trading shares or in trading leveraged products. He also wrote that the purpose of opening his account with City Credit was for “capital growth,” and that he had no interest in engaging in speculative trading, the claim says.

Alongside the form Dupuis also signed a limited power of attorney agreement that would authorize someone to carry out trades on his behalf. Dupuis was told leave this part of the form blank and that the name Javier Baldriz, a foreign exchange trader based in Uruguay, was added at a later date.

Dupuis says he later explained to City Credit staff during a meeting in London that he was a “conservative” investor, would need to be able to make withdrawals at any time and that he had no trading experience, the suit claims.

Lawyers for Dupuis say he was therefore reliant on the advice of City Credit and senior broker Malcolm Hayward, who was appointed his account manager to explain the performance of his investments while he was preoccupied with running his nursing home business.

During phone calls Hayward told Dupuis to ignore parts of the statements he was receiving about his account and made favorable misrepresentations about its performance, the suit says. Hayward also wrote that the profits being generated “are second to none” without giving an overall state of the account.

At no time during the setting up of the account was Dupuis “provided with a proper explanation or description of the products being traded,” the suit says, or with any documents to help understand the he might lose more than the sums he invested.

The suit accuses the defendants of breaching Financial Conduct Authority rules which caused Dupuis to suffer loss and damages.

Had the company carried a proper assessment of the appropriateness of whether it was appropriate for Dupuis to open a foreign exchange trading account they would have warned him against it, the claim states.

The suit claims that Haywood was not authorized by the FCA to perform a “consumer function” and should not have been providing “further advice” to Dupuis. 

Dupuis argues that he should be able to recoup the sums lost as a result of the trading on his account and the incentive fees deducted by City Credit.