Not-for-profit caught up in staff car crash claim
LONDON: A not-for-profit wants to void liability for a car crash in which a staffer was seriously injured whilst driving to her mother’s home after a work incident.
In Mission Australia v Alexandria Kate Eves, Deputy President Elizabeth Wood of the Workers Compensation Commission of New South Wales considered whether:
- the worker had suffered injuries
- the worker’s psychological condition was due to reasonable administrative action
- the original judge was in error.
The worker, Alexandria Kate Eves, worked as a community support worker for the employer, Mission Australia. On 19 February 2016 the worker was driving to her mother’s home after a work incident when she was involved in a car crash. She suffered significant injuries.
The worker sought compensation for her crash-related injuries. The employer denied the claim and the case was brought to court. In the original hearing the judge found in favour of the worker. The employer appealed the decision.
The worker began work with the employer on 2 March 2015. She experienced several stressful events and consulted her doctor, who certified her unfit for work from 11 February 2016. The worker returned to work on 19 February 2016 with the condition that she not have to interact with a superior, Karen Howarth, who had been associated with the stressful events.
On the day the worker returned to work, the superior approached the worker and talked to her. The worker’s injury management adviser told the worker to cease work for two weeks so a more effective return to work plan could be put in place.
The worker was very upset at the failure of her return to work. She decided to stay with her mother for the two weeks and spent the day packing, obtaining medication and trying to pay her rent. She did not leave until around 6.30pm. The car crash occurred at 8.30pm.
The employer argued the worker’s crash was not work-related. The employer argued that any injuries or psychological conditions were not work-related. The employer argued that if it was found the worker sustained a psychological injury due to her work, that injury was because of reasonable administrative action and therefore not compensable.
During the original hearing the worker stated that the delay in travelling to her mother’s after work was caused by her reaction to the work situation. The worker stated she had spent the day in shock, feeling blank and forgetting to do things, while also trying to take care of the details of the situation, such as informing her insurer about what had happened. The worker argued that she would not have been travelling in the car if she had not been instructed by the employer to go home, which was not her temporary accommodation near her work but her mother’s house.
The original judge found that the worker had been on a journey from work to her mother’s home at the time of the accident. The judge found that the actions taken by the worker during the day formed part of that journey and that the worker’s employment had contributed to the accident. The employer argued that the judge was in error.
In deciding the case, Deputy President Wood reviewed the original judge’s decision and found no errors. Deputy President Wood noted that previous decisions had set a precedent for the worker’s claim to be approved. Deputy President Wood found the original decision was correct and dismissed the appeal.






