Is disability architecture the final design frontier
LONDON: ‘There is a general taboo around disability where people feel they need to hide it if they can,’ says Amy Francis-Smith, vice-president of the Birmingham Architectural Association.
‘I have [become] more outspoken on the issue in a hope that it will encourage others to open up about their own experiences.’
Architecture’s issues with gender, race and sexuality diversity have faced increasing scrutiny in recent years. But disability is another area where improvement is desperately needed.
Although one in five working-age adults in the UK are classed as disabled, according to charity Scope, latest figures suggest a significantly lower proportion for those working in architecture.
Fewer than 1 per cent of respondents to a survey by the Architects’ Registration Board this August described themselves as having a disability.
The AJ spoke to four people at different stages of their architectural careers about their experiences studying and working with a disability.
The interviews highlight the barriers that make it harder to enter the profession as well as the ways in which practices miss out by not tapping into this well of talent and life experience.
From cantilevered reception desks to narrow corridors, our interviews reveal the way simple design flaws throughout buildings make life harder for a fifth of the population.
While the pandemic may have indirectly created better working conditions for some disabled architects, it has also added to the challenge in other ways.
Amid the lessons that the industry can learn, one thing is overwhelming clear: there is a strong desire among those we talked to for the voice of the disabled community to be heard louder and more often.
Amy Francis-Smith
Part 3 architectural assistant at Pinnegar Hayward Design in Birmingham. Lives with multiple chronic illnesses
‘I had health issues from birth,’ says Francis-Smith, 29. ‘After completing the first year of my masters at the University of Westminster in 2015, I became drastically ill. I was going into full blown anaphylaxis almost daily. My body rejected everything.
‘I was diagnosed with Mast Cell Activation Syndrome, which is a systemic condition that affects your heart, lungs, kidneys – I had skin rashes, my spleen hurt all the time, my eyesight was going. I was then diagnosed with Crohn’s in my colon and Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, which means my joints dislocate randomly, and I had some internal organ issues.’
While still very poorly herself, Francis-Smith stepped in to help a neighbour plan out a bungalow after seeing how badly his house was adapted when he developed motor neurone disease.
‘The council put in a step but he needed a ramp, and then they wanted to put a bathroom in his living room, devaluing his property and reducing space for family life,’ she says. ‘It inspired me to get into accessible architecture and fight for change.’
After moving to the Midlands to recuperate, Francis-Smith switched her studies to Birmingham City University and completed her masters last year.
‘I want to work but there are barriers I face,’ she says. ‘For someone with a chronic illness or invisible disability it can be both easier and harder to ask for accommodations – I am good at looking like I function normally but behind that is a very strict routine I have to adhere to.
‘I have weekly injection appointments so only work four days a week. I bring in things like my own soap because I react to the one in the office.’
Managing her energy levels is a constant priority, although this has been aided by the work-from-home edict issued by ministers this year.
‘Although the pandemic has been an awful time for a lot of people, there is a positive,’ she says. ‘Half the battle for me was often the commuting time each day.’
Designing natural ventilation into buildings would be a huge immediate benefit to sufferers of her condition. ‘I am like the canary in the mine,’ she says. ‘The toxic stew we live in will affect me first but it will end up affecting everyone.’
Quiet rooms, more seating and better signage would all help conserve energy levels in people with chronic illnesses, she adds.
‘Basically don’t use Part M of the Building Regulations as a tack-on at the end of a design. Accessibility now is like sustainability was 20 years ago when they just stuck solar panels on the roof and called it an eco-building. We need to go on that journey. Inclusive design is improved by talking directly to users and planning it in from the beginning.’
Francis-Smith is completing her Part 3 and hoping to be a fully qualified architect very soon after a journey that has taken her over a decade. She is vice-president of the Birmingham Architecture Association and teaches inclusive design at Birmingham University.
‘I am keen to make sure all the architecture schools in the country educate students about inclusive design and bring more disabled students on to their courses,’ she says.
‘To anyone with a chronic illness, be kind to yourself. You can get through it. And someone needs to make changes to the world, so why not let it be you? Call the council, complain to the shopping centre – get into architecture and prevent inaccessible spaces from being built.’
Ben Stephens
Founder of East Midlands practice Paste Architects. Is profoundly deaf
‘I had a complicated birth,’ says 43-year-old Stephens. ‘My hearing either did not develop in the womb or it was lost during the birth.
‘I was always known to be good at drawing and maths. I did a careers questionnaire at school and the results told me I could be an architect, a structural engineer or a product designer. I chose to be an architect. ‘
There were many challenges to overcome to achieve that ambition.
‘At university, my friends would take notes in lectures and I would read them later.
‘I was held back in the early years of my career as I couldn’t use a phone. I was never the number one running a project.
‘I mainly communicate by lip-reading with support of a cochlear implant device. In an architects’ office there are a lot of group meetings with clients and contractors, and different people are talking from different angles so it can be difficult to pick up.’
In 2010 Stephens started his own practice, working from home and using ever-improving modern technology to his advantage.
‘Communication has come on since the early 2000s – email, video phones and speech-to-text interpreters. It doesn’t hold me back as it used to,’ he says.
‘In a way the lockdown has been good as more people are using video calls, which enables me to see captions of what people are saying.’
Stephens’ communication skills can be an advantage on a project. He is scrupulous about getting details in writing and has learned ways to understand instruction without using his ears. ‘At university I could lip-read someone 10m away in a nightclub,’ he laughs. ‘On the IKEA Coventry project there were 500 people on site at one time and I could still lip-read what the project manager was saying with the construction noise all around us.’
Stephens says society still doesn’t take deaf people into consideration. ‘Look at the prime minister’s announcements on the coronavirus – there is no sign language in the background.’
This theme continues into the built environment, he warns, with buildings not just lacking visual announcements but laid out in a way that doesn’t help the deaf.
‘Ideally there needs to be 2m spacing between people for effective lip-reading and it’s the same for sign language,’ he says. ‘So we need wider corridors and also the right wall colours – it is hard to read the hands of a person if the wall colour is similar to that of their skin tone.’
Another common, if seemingly innocuous problem, is right-angled corners.
‘Someone can walk into another person coming the other way as a deaf person can’t hear footsteps approaching. Ideally corners should be curved or chamfered.’
Even the sign language for the word ‘architect’ – drawing a line from the elbow to the hand – is ‘old fashioned’ says Stephens. ‘It is based on an architect using a drawing board and large ruler.’
Deaf awareness training should be compulsory for practices hiring someone who is deaf, he says, to enable better communications and understanding.
‘If a deaf person is the best architect for a job then they are worth the extra bit of investment in time and money to get the best out of them.’
Stephens is director of Surdi Domum Group, which is working to design buildings ‘for deaf people by deaf people’. He is also applying for a grant towards development of affordable housing and extra-care facilities for the deaf.
His words of advice for a deaf teenager considering a career in the profession are ‘to not let anything hold them back … you need perseverance.’
Poppy Levison
Part 1 architecture student at University of the Arts London Central Saint Martins. Is visually impaired
‘I have very little peripheral vision and my central vision is significantly worse than a sighted person,’ says Levison. ‘I have double vision so I see two of everything. I navigate the world using a white cane and use technology to make things bigger, as well as screen readers.’
After she showed an interest in architecture, Levison was taken by her mother to see Central Saint Martins and ‘fell in love with it,’ she says.‘It was the first university that made adjustments for my disability at the open day.’
Levison has faced challenges in moving to London and studying architecture.
‘There are things that make it harder to study,’ she says. ‘I can’t just walk into a library and read a book. I would struggle even to find the book. I read them, much-enlarged, online or have my computer read them out to me.
‘There is no standard way for a visually impaired person to do architecture – as well as doing the course I am working out how to do the course.’
She has, however, developed skills she can use to her advantage.
‘I have time organisation strategies that my friends are envious of,’ she says. ‘Like making sure things are where you expect them to be, whether digitally or physically.’
Levison would like to see a built environment that could more easily be suited to individual requirements.
‘Places that can be adapted to someone’s needs are important,’ she says. ‘If I sit in a library and can’t adjust the lighting, it can make a big impact. But not every visually impaired person has the same needs.
‘The plan of a building can have a massive impact on accessibility – making it predictable, so toilets are in the same place on every floor, reduces time spent wayfinding.’
The pandemic has made aspects of her life harder, with more signage to negotiate as well as a reluctance to use her hands as much. ‘When I go to a new site I would naturally be using my sense of touch to greater understand the area,’ she explains.
She believes practices would benefit hugely from more diversity of experience.
‘Architecture culture is really inaccessible,’ she says. ‘It is predominately image-based and often the images don’t have descriptions. Often I can’t even negotiate an architect’s website using a screen reader. Some have three lines describing a project and all the rest is pictures.
‘There are so many elements that are not welcoming that it can feel like it is not for you.’
Levison has had to go to extreme lengths to maintain her progression in architecture.
‘Over the summer we were sent off to learn [modelling] software that had no accessibility settings,’ she says. ‘In order to use it, I’ve learned to code, then I’ve learned to code for the software and now I can 3D model entirely by writing down what I want to be there in text.
‘Software firms could easily make their products more accessible.’
But she urges disabled people not to be put off the profession. ‘Find the community of people; we are small but we exist,’ she says. Recognise that everything you do is going to make it easier for the people who come after you.’
Roseanne Scott
Architect based at the London studio of Norwich-headquartered LSI Architects. Has achondroplasia dwarfism
‘All members of my family have dwarfism so the house I grew up in had been adapted, which meant I could be independent at home,’ says Scott, who is 28. ‘But at a lot of places I went to as a kid I could not open doors or walk up stairs. These experiences influenced me to want to get into architecture to make a change.’
The journey has not been without its obstacles, as shown on a trip to Paris in her first year at university.
‘It wasn’t well managed,’ she recalls, ‘and they made me walk too far so I was in severe pain. On average I take two steps for every one an average-height person takes. I took a micro-scooter on the next trip, and someone else did the lifting if there was a laptop to be carried all day.’
Standing up for herself and having the confidence to address people are abilities that have stood her in good stead in the workplace.
‘I have been on site as the architectural representative but not been addressed in conversation or asked the design question,’ she says. ‘In one instance, a group of men had a discussion over my head. You have to make them aware you are in the room.’
Scott says the skills she’s had to learn have helped her network. ‘You are also more memorable,’ she quips.
The only thing that holds Scott back professionally, she says, are other people’s perceptions. ‘There is no reason I should be any better or worse as an architect because I have dwarfism.
‘But you do feel that you have to try harder; I got a first at undergrad level and a 2:1 at masters. I was also doing additional work experience and volunteering.’
There are elements of her life experience that she can use to improve the design of projects.
‘In my first year out, working for a small practice, I did a residential project for a wheelchair user,’ she says. ‘I am 1.2m tall which is about the same height as someone in a wheelchair. It gives you an understanding of how spaces can be experienced differently.’
This outlook, she adds, benefits her current work in the healthcare sector. ‘I will make sure there are no sharp corners, no cantilever over a desk making it harder to reach over.’
She would like to see architects think more about how the accessibility features they design will actually be used.
‘Sometimes lifts are back of house and there can be different entrances, so we’re not getting the same experience as others,’ she says. ‘The space can be so tight that you wouldn’t be able to use it in a wheelchair. I am always asking: Does it need to be this small?’
Scott is very keen to use her own career to bring more disabled people into the profession.
‘If I knew there were more people in the industry with disabilities then I would have been able to speak to them before I was even at university to talk about the barriers I would face,’ she says.
Scott is committed to developing her advocacy role. She speaks on panels, acts as a mentor and sits on the committee of the RIBA’s Re-Fabricate Waste Reuse initiative.
‘My advice for someone who is disabled would be to plan what they want to do, and find their own ways to adapt,’ she says. ‘Find as much help as you can, even if you don’t need it, as you might do later.
‘Be confident, network and find people who are disabled with whom you can find commonality. Reach out to people.’






