Lawsuit against village owners alleges negligence and wrongful death
LONDON: A flurry of lawsuits against retirement village and residential care operators is threatening to make the sector unbankable.
A $110-million dollar lawsuit has been filed against Schlegel Villages, the company which operates the Village at St. Clair in Windsor, over its handling of COVID-19 outbreak where dozens died.
In a statement of claim put forward by lawyer Gary Will, lead council on the suit for Will Davidson LLP, the proposed class action lawsuit alleges the company “failed to protect” residents of Schlegel Village-owned Long Term Care and Retirement homes from a mass spread of COVID-19.
“The family members that have contacted us who have lost loved ones, they want answers to why this happened, who’s responsible and how’s this situation going to be turned around so no family ever has to go through this ever again,” Will said.
The Village at St. Clair saw a major outbreak of COVID-19 in December. The outbreak was lifted at that facility on Thursday with the health unit reporting a total of 177 resident cases and 143 cases among staff members.
There were 63 resident deaths at the Village at St. Clair as a result of COVID-19 according to the province.
The lawsuit alleges negligence, gross negligence, breach of the Occupiers’ Liability Act, breach of fiduciary duty, breach of the human rights code and wrongful death.
It alleges that Schlegel Villages had “inadequate preventative and responsive measures to the COVID-19 pandemic,” and as a result there was a “mass spread of COVID-19 at multiple Schlegel Villages-owned LTC and retirement homes.”
None of the allegations have been tested in court and the suit still needs to be certified by the court as a class action.
Schlegel Villages declined a request for an interview, but in an emailed statement said it would address any allegations through the legal processes.
While the plaintiff listed on the claim was a resident in Mississauga’s Erin Mills lodge, the claim seeks to represent all persons who were residing at a Shlegel-Villages-owned long term care and retirement home during the pandemic period.
In Windsor, that also includes the Village at Aspen Lake. It had a further 11 deaths.
Will said that the suit will include those who contracted COVID, as well as the estates and family members of those who died because of it. He said the suit will also cover residents who were in the homes and who suffered during the pandemic because they didn’t receive the proper level of care.
“They’re all vulnerable residents. They’re entirely dependent on their caregivers and they’re not getting what they contracted for.”
In the statement, Schlegel Villages said its teams have faced unprecedented challenges during the pandemic and followed every guidance of Ontario’s Chief Medical Officer of Health.
“We know how hard it has been for residents and their loved ones and our deepest condolences are with those who faced loss because of COVID-19; we all feel that grief, for the residents we serve are part of our family,” the statement read.
“Throughout the course of the pandemic, we have made every effort to be entirely open and transparent with families and our neighbours in the community, and we will continue to do so.”
In a press release today about the lifting of the outbreak at the Village of St. Clair, it also said that more than 97 percent of residents in the home have also now received at least a first dose of the Moderna vaccine.






