Care group fights off litigant who won’t back off

LONDON: A care group is fighting a new force with which it cannot avoid. The legal attack dog who won’t give up. Now a care group has sought the protection of the court to gain some relief from the onslaught.

In Ayan Abdi Hassan v Sydney Local Health District, Bell P, Basten JA and Leeming JA of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales considered whether:

  • the application was vexatious
  • the previous judge was in error
  • the requests should be dismissed.

The applicant, Ayan Abdi Hassan, was trying to appeal a decision and had filed several requests with the court. On 20 May 2021 a judge dismissed most of the applicant’s requests without hearing. The judge found that two of the requests could remain for hearing as long as the applicant filed her submissions by 21 June 2021. The applicant did not file her submissions and the last requests in her case were dismissed on 22 June 2021.

On 18 June 2021 the applicant sought orders that the previous judges’ orders be overturned and that the judges in her case be referred to the Commonwealth Parliament. On 22 June 2021 the court ordered the applicant to file reasons of no more than ten pages as to why her new requests were not an abuse of process. This hearing was to decide that issue.

The applicant had originally filed a case against the hospital over a muscle biopsy which she claimed she had not consented to. The court dismissed her case. The applicant filed an appeal and lost. She continued to pursue an appeal through every avenue she could find over the course of 12 months, including asking the court to issue subpoenas, to agree to review previous decisions and asking to put new evidence before the court.

The applicant had not filed her reasons with the court as requested.

In deciding the case, the judges found that as the applicant had not filed reasons as requested her requests should be dismissed. The judges also found that an order should be made that if the applicant filed any further requests or cases with the court they be reviewed to see whether they were vexatious.