Families that pay together are getting multigenerational living right
LONDON: Sue Putnam is typical of a new wave of retirees who are living with – and helping to look after – three or more generations of their family.
Putnam, who for years provided assistance to her ageing parents, has moved into a purpose-built multi-generational home with her daughter’s family in Queensland’s Palm Grove.
“I can help my daughter look after her children and provide financial support helping to pay for the home,” says the former finance officer for the University of Sydney, who retired on a defined benefit pension in 2017.
Putnam is one of the rapidly growing “club sandwich” generation of parents who not only have to pay for their retirement but assist with older generations, children and grandchildren.
Liz Allen, a demographer with the Australian National University, says anecdotal evidence shows the number of families with multiple retired generations is rapidly increasing.
Longer life expectancies, the rising cost of living and housing, along with women having children later in life, mean retirees will also be expected to provide financial and care support, Allen says.
“There are many, many tiers to this sandwich,” she says.
Multigenerational living is having a growing impact on home designs finances, legal relationships and estate planning, particularly when aggrieved children believe they have received less from a parent’s estate than other siblings.
One in five Australians lives in multigenerational households, with the number rising to one in four in Sydney, according to the Australian Bureau of Statistics.
For a grandmother like Putnam, sharing her finances and living in a self-contained apartment in her daughter’s home, is “an absolute gift”.
“I think it is a normal and happy way to live,” she says.
But for others, intergenerational living can contribute to irreconcilable differences that routinely result in bitter divisions and expensive legal disputes.
Allen warns it can also be a “perfect incubator” for elder abuse as inheritance-impatient children pressure their parents – or even steal – to get hold of their assets.
This is what specialists recommend doing to make the best of sharing finances and family space – plus mistakes to avoid.
Sharing a home
The Commonwealth Bank, the nation’s largest lender, offers property share mortgages that allow multiple borrowers to buy one property and split the cost while keeping their finances separate.
Borrowers must demonstrate they can manage the minimum required repayments for their own section of the loan and be prepared to guarantee the other borrowers.
They can split the loan any way they like – say, 50:50 or 75:25 – and decide on the type, such as fixed or variable.
Those considering this strategy need advice from experienced lawyers and financial advisers to ensure their liability reflects their share of the property, strategies for resolving problems, estate planning issues and a deed or agreement setting out who pays which bills.
Courts and tribunals are kept busy unravelling family disputes caused by undocumented deals based on a handshake, or verbal agreements falling apart because of misunderstandings or changing circumstances.
Builders Metricon and GJ Gardner Homes design and build houses for multigenerational living that have plenty of bathrooms, toilets and spaces for different generations to call their own.
“Our most popular are where most bedrooms, if not all, have their own ensuite and a floor plan with several distinct living areas
– and a guest bedroom located on the ground floor with an ensuite and walk-in-wardrobes to ensure elderly-friendly accessibility,” says Drew Glascott, Metricon’s general manager of sales and marketing.
The building company has 70 house designs and a further 130 designs that can be modified to provide multigenerational living, Glascott says.
GJ Gardner chief executive Trent Gardner says multigenerational homes often have higher resale values because they can cater for a broader range of buyers.
“Multigenerational living can help distribute the financial burden of housing expenses by sharing the costs of living, such as mortgage payments, utilities and groceries,” Gardner says.
Yelena Smetannikov, an architect with inner-Sydney Urban Den Architects, says there is strong demand from people wanting to have their homes modified for different generations, or designing houses that can be converted.
“Ninety per cent want some form of separation – say, the owners living upstairs and extended family downstairs, or grandparents living in a backyard granny flat,” Smetannikov says.
James Kirkland, head of sales for Little Real Estate, which has offices in NSW, Victoria and Queensland, says multigenerational living has become popular since the COVID-19 pandemic as families considered alternative ways of entering the expensive property market.
Avoid damaging disputes
All parties need to take independent financial and legal advice so they are aware of their obligations before they sign any agreements, warns Alexandra Tighe, a partner with lawyers Holding Redlich.
If it involves a loan, there should be a financial agreement setting out repayment terms, interest rates and the lender’s rights on default.
A promised share of the eventual sale price needs details about who owns what percentage.
“You need to make sure everyone is working on the same assumptions,” says Tighe. “If it is not written down, then it is not clear.”
Parents also must specify in their wills whether any family debt will be forgiven and ensure that other beneficiaries, such as siblings, will not be disadvantaged.
“If there are other children, make sure the will is kept up to date and that there is provision for equalisation, which ensures that any assets that were previously distributed to beneficiaries are accounted for in the distribution of the estate,” says Tighe.
Owners should be cautious about how the home is registered to avoid half the property automatically passing to the other joint tenant on their death.
Or they could own the property 50:50 as tenants in common – an arrangement where two or more people can co-own the same property, but the survivor does not automatically take the interest of the person who has died.
“This should be in writing on both the property title and will,” says Tighe.
There should also be a scheme for resolving disputes and an exit strategy. The latter should include provision for the property’s independent valuation and, if necessary, dispute resolution such as mediation.
“Most parties do not want to go through the time and expense of litigation,” she says. “The more that can be pre-agreed, the more likely that it is clear to all parties and the fewer grounds for dispute.”
Phoebe Blamey, mortgage broker and director Clover Financial Solutions, warns that a loan will affect the parent’s borrowing capacity and could be costly to unwind because of potential capital gains tax and stamp duty.
Beware elder abuse
A father recently had his superannuation savings totalling around $240,000 unknowingly taken from his account to pay the mortgage on his son’s account, the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal was told.
The son, who was not named in the proceedings, says he took the money as compensation for time spent looking after his father, a former electrical engineer, and “to enable him to work less”, the tribunal heard.
The tribunal would not let him appeal the revocation of his right to manage his father’s estate.
“The son was appointed financial manager,” says Darryl Browne, a lawyer with Browne Linkenbagh Legal Services.
“That fact is important because a financial manager is regularly reviewed – at least annually – and this helped bring the son’s actions to the tribunal’s attention.
“If the son had been appointed as the father’s attorney [a legal trustee to manage financial affairs], his actions would have been effectively invisible.”
About one in 10 Australians will be affected by financial elder abuse.
The problem is expected to accelerate as the population ages and the number of retiring Baby Boomers ramps up, says the Australian Banking Association.
“In this case the son misunderstood his responsibilities to act in the best interests of the father, not his own interests,” says Browne. According to the Australian Human Rights Commission, the most common forms of elder abuse are relatives extorting money and social control, such as restricting social contact.
Increased financial pressures are likely to raise the risk of elder abuse, typically by family members with a strong sense of entitlement to their parents’ property, specialists warn.
How to get it right
Prevent the value of a parent’s interest in the home being counted as an asset for any means-tested Centrelink support.
Most real estate assets are included in the assets test, excluding the principal home and up to the first two hectares of land it occupies.
Consider what might happen if either party is forced to sell their share, compelling the other to sell. Will they be able to repurchase a new home in the same neighbourhood, close to similar amenities?
Partners with equal shares who want to have a divisible interest on death should consider registering as tenants in common instead of joint registered proprietors, to avoid half the property automatically passing to the other joint tenant on their death.
Tenants in common with unequal shares should record the extent of the interest clearly on the title and in a separate written document to avoid later disputes.
Agreements must be in writing and signed by all parties after legal and financial advice explaining rights and obligations. Create a separate deed setting out who pays which bills.
Renovations or additional payments by one party could entitle them to a greater share. Specify terms and conditions and ensure they are understood when the property is purchased.
Wills should include equalisation strategies between spouses, long-term partners and children. Update it regularly and as circumstances change.
Agree to a way for resolving disputes, such as mediation, and an exit strategy. Try to anticipate problems and strategies for resolution.






