Resident revolt triggers collapse in share price of retiree village operator
LONDON: The business model of land lease providers coupling rent and a deferred management fee (DMF) is now in significant doubt.
Despite the confidence of existing operators, the forum chosen for resolution of the challenge by an army of angry residents, has a history of pinging the land lease operator.
Shares in mid-cap developer Lifestyle Communities have plunged more than 18 per cent after allegations were aired on the ABC by residents of a Victorian community challenging the company’s deferred management fees model.
Residents at the $1.27bn company’s Wollert community in northwest Melbourne, which had been marketed as low-maintenance, affordable, resort-style living, have lodged a claim against Lifestyle Communities in the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal over fees they believed were excessive and in breach of the law.
They also claimed there was lack of initial transparency about the fee mode which is based on a 20 per cent exit fee based on the value of the house when sold after five years.
However, in a statement to the ASX, Lifestyle Communities said it had engaged with residents since February and it rejected the allegations made in relation to its deferred management fees in the VCAT applications and will defend them accordingly.
“Deferred management fees (DMF) are permissible in all states except for South Australia. In Victoria, most land lease operators charge a deferred management fee,” it told investors on Monday. “The group members that we met with acknowledged that they fully understood that the DMF was in their site agreements and was payable as a percentage of their resale price when they moved out.”
Lifestyle Communities said it took its compliance obligations extremely seriously and had obtained legal advice throughout its 21 years to ensure it operated in accordance with relevant legislation, and its policies was consistent with other industry operators.
The company said it had always taken pride in the transparency provided throughout its sales process. It said key elements of the process included all fees clearly articulated and explained on its website and in marketing materials.
The company started in 2003 and has 22 land lease communities in Victoria, and about 5300 homeowners with its main competitors in the over 50s land lease community sector including Ingenia, Mirvac and Stockland. It is backed by AustralianSuper, which owns a 12 per cent stake.
The model has attracted some criticism, with claims by some investors that the fee structure was not competitive in a crowded market, while analysts had downgraded the stock.
In the six months to the end of 2023, Lifestyle Communities recorded a net profit after tax of $20.8m compared to $25.2m in the prior comparative period affected by lower new home settlements because the weak Victorian property market appeared to be pushing out decisions to sell existing homes.
The company said the average time to resell a home in Lifestyle Communities in the 2024 financial year was 63 days.
It said over the past 10 years homeowners had achieved an average annual house price growth of 9.5 per cent.
The company in February launched a $275m equity-raising $16 a share after downgrading earnings forecasts.
The stock closed down 18.1 per cent at $10.30 on Monday.






