Old people scare me says Gen Z commentator
LONDON: Teens are baffled previous generations did so many adult things so young, says a Gen Z commentator.
What’s wrong with kids today? They don’t drink, do drugs or have sex like they used to. Is that even a problem?
“Whatever we call them, they are different,” writes world-renowned psychologist Professor Jean Twenge in her 2023 book, Generations.
“[They] are concerned with authenticity, confronting free speech issues, pushing the norms of gender and struggling with mental health.”
They also learn to drive and leave home later than previous generations, are older when they enter the workforce, hold a dim view of capitalism, and, most importantly, are welded to their smartphones.
“The traditional theories of generations rely on the impact of major events on their lives – economic cycles, wars, and pandemics,” says Twenge, who will appear at the Festival of Dangerous Ideas in August.
“But now what differentiates generations is changes in technology: smartphones and social media; faster transportation; laboursaving devices and better medical care.
“The impacts of technology dramatically change how we live our lives and there are downstream effects as well. Better medical care and more education for technologically complex societies means that people take longer to grow up and grow old.”
In other words, the 18-year-olds of today look more like 14-year-olds in previous generations.
“Gen Z is not just extending adolescence; they are extending childhood, taking longer to step into the activities of adults,” she writes in Generations.
It’s what Twenge has dubbed the “slow life strategy”, which is an adaptation to the times in which Gen Z live.
And while they know they are missing out on some of the fun, they are “baffled that previous generations did so many adult things while so young”.
As one early teen said when told that in the 1990s, kids in Year 8 sometimes drank alcohol: “Old people sometimes scare me.”
But Gen Zs also scare older people, with their proclivity for depression, sadness, loneliness, self-harm and suicide.
Twenge, a professor of psychology at San Diego State University who has been tracking shifts in generational attitudes and outlooks for more than 30 years, was one of the first people to link smartphones and social media to the decline in emotional and mental health since 2012.
It was her 2017 book, iGen, and an article in The Atlantic that garnered worldwide attention and then a backlash.
“The article went viral and got a lot of people talking,” Twenge says. “And as so often happens in public discourse and academia, most of [the response to her work] was that I was just plain wrong before the discussion completely turned around over the past seven years.”
Twenge and collaborator Jonathan Haidt have become figureheads for a movement of parents, academics, educators, policymakers and politicians who are gaining ground on putting pressure on social media companies to put age limits on social media apps.
In May, US Surgeon-General Vivek Murthy issued a public warning about excessive social media use by teenagers, labelling it as an emergency and urging tobacco-style warnings on the various platforms.
“Adolescents who spend more than three hours a day on social media face double the risk of anxiety and depression symptoms, and the average daily use in this age group, as of the summer of 2023, was 4.8 hours. Additionally, nearly half of adolescents say social media makes them feel worse about their bodies,” he wrote in The New York Times.
Murthy called on Congress to introduce laws that would force social media companies to “shield young people from online harassment, abuse and exploitation and from exposure to extreme violence and sexual content that too often appears in algorithm-driven feeds”.
There is rising traction for social media controls in Australia, too. Opposition Leader Peter Dutton has pledged to ban under-16-year-olds from accessing social media by implementing age verification in the first 100 days of a Coalition government.
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese hasn’t gone so far, but has said social media was having “a negative impact on young people”.
A survey from NAB released earlier this week sheds some light on how teenagers feel about such bans.
Overall, they believe that social media has a positive effect on them and their peers and that it helps keep them connected, included and accepted.
But the feelings were mixed. While one in three said they felt supported on social media when the going got tough, one in four felt the opposite.
“The research shows that social media gives teenagers agency and connects them with others with shared interests, identities and self-expression,” says Dean Pearson, head of behavioural and industry economics for NAB.
“But there is a clear gender split. Boys are much more likely to say social media helps them feel supported, while girls say the opposite. The vulnerability for girls appears that it seems to expose them a little bit more.”
Pearson says there are two types of human motivation: agency and communion.
“Agency is trying to expand the self, while communion is integrating the self into a larger social unit. Boys and men tend to focus on agency, while girls focus on communion, so that leans into some of the pressures girls feel like social comparison and perfectionism.”
Twenge, however, does not flinch from her belief that children and teenagers should be protected from social media until they are old enough to be able to understand and process what is thrown at them by algorithms.
As she writes in Generations, the number of teens and young adults with clinical-level depression more than doubled in the decade to 2021, affecting nearly 30 per cent of teenage girls and 12 per cent of teen boys.
Suicide rates of 10-14 year olds tripled and nearly quadrupled for girls.
“Let that sink in,” she writes. “Twice as many teens were taking their own lives in 2019 than just 12 years before and three times as many kids in 4th to 9th grade died at their own hands.”
The number of young lives in the US that have been lost would be enough to “fill nine planes”.
“Imagine if nine airline flights with 10-24 year olds crashed every single year, killing everyone on board. Airlines would not be allowed to fly again until we figured out why so many were crashing. Yet, that is how many more additional lives have been lost to suicide among American young people since 2007.”
Of course, the epidemic is not just American. It is being replicated across the Western world.
As the mother of three teenage daughters aged 12, 14 and 17, Twenge is in the thick of it.
Her rule is no internet-enabled smart-phone until they are old enough to get a driver’s licence.
“Sure there is peer group pressure, but they have pretty well accepted it,” Twenge says, adding that she’s sure her next book will be writing for parents on how to guide and manage kids and teens in the era of technology.
The Festival of Dangerous Ideas will be held at Carriageworks in Sydney on August 24-25.






