Assisted living rent growth lags behind wage growth claims report

LONDON: Assisted living asking rent growth generally has lagged behind the pace of wage growth in the sector in recent years, according to a new analysis by the National Investment Center for Seniors Housing & Care.

In a recent blog post, Lisa McCracken, head of NIC’s research and analytics team, compared cumulative rent growth against wage growth within assisted living from the first quarter of 2020 through the third quarter of 2024.

Labor costs accounted for a “notable share” of expenses, according to Omar Zahraoui, NIC senior principal, but operators also faced challenges tied to other operating cots, like utilities and insurance. Wage growth, on the other hand surged due to workforce shortages that were further exacerbated by inflation.

“While we have greater stability than two years ago, there are still uncertainties as we start off 2025,” Zahraoui said. “While inflation has moderated, labor costs remain elevated, and economic uncertainty continues to keep operators cautious.”

Structural issues, he added, such as labor force participation and availability in senior housing remain unresolved. And proposed immigration restrictions could further tighten labor markets, exacerbate shortages and drive up costs for operators.

Assisted living asking rents grew 23% from the first quarter of 2020 to the third quarter of 2024, compared with a 29% increase in wage growth for all assisted living staff. Wage growth among assisted living production and non-supervisory staff — which comprise approximately 80% of wages in the sector — grew 42% in that time, according to NIC.

McCracken said that the wage and rent growth dynamics were set against the roller coaster ride that the nation’s economy and labor markets have been on since early 2020. Many people voluntarily resigned from their jobs in 2021 during the COVID-19 pandemic in the Great Resignation, which brought escalating wages and tight labor markets. That year, operators also experienced surging inflation, she said.

The gap between asking rents and wages, however, doesn’t give operators a pass to implement “widespread aggressive rent hikes,” McCracken said. Rents, she added, always have been driven by a combination of factors.

Although the sector overall was able to implement larger rate increases during the high inflationary years in the shadow of the pandemic, and those rate increases generally were accepted by consumers, operators considering rent hikes today must consider what expenses their organizations can absorb and what can be passed on to existing and future residents, she wrote.

Affordability of senior housing is a growing concern among older adults, as living expenses are increasing. For those who can afford it, the ability and willingness to pay will be there, Zahraoui said. The concern is for those who fall outside of the range in ability to pay for many private-pay senior living options. He said a 2023 NIC analysis highlighted the need for operators to understand what current and potential residents can afford, as steep rate increases may impact move-ins, demand growth and occupancy levels.

What remains to be seen, McCracken said, is how rent growth will pace this year and next. Keeping in mind that older adults will have the lowest Social Security cost-of-living adjustment in four years, operators must look at how that fact plays into rent-setting and how the overall affordability of the housing market informs the costs of senior housing.

“I believe the industry will continue to focus its energies on leasing vacant units, reducing discounts, and improving overall efficiency and margins,” American Seniors Housing Association President and CEO David Schless previously said.