Doctors fear AI assistance is making them worse at their jobs
LONDON: In the past few years, studies have described the many ways artificial intelligence tools have made doctors better at their jobs: it’s aided them in spotting cancer, has allowed them to make diagnoses faster and, in some cases, helped them more accurately predict who is at risk of complications.
But new research suggests collaborating with AI may have a hidden cost.
A study published in the Lancet Gastroenterology and Hepatology found that after just three months of using an AI tool designed to help spot precancerous growths during colonoscopies, doctors were significantly worse at finding the growths on their own.
This is the first evidence that relying on AI tools might erode a doctor’s ability to perform fundamental skills without the technology, a phenomenon known as “de-skilling”.
“This is a two-way process,” said Omer Ahmad, a gastroenterologist at University College Hospital London who published an editorial alongside the study. “We give AI inputs that affect its output, but it also seems to affect our behaviour as well.”
The study began like many AI trials in medicine. Doctors at four endoscopy centres in Poland were given access to an AI tool that flagged suspicious growths while they performed a colonoscopy, drawing a box around them in real time.
Several other large clinical trials have shown this technology significantly improves doctors’ detection rate of precancerous growths, a widely accepted indicator of an endoscopist’s performance.
Then, unlike in past studies, the researchers measured what happened when the tool was taken away.
In the three months before the technology was introduced, the doctors spotted growths in about 28 per cent of colonoscopies. Now, the detection rate had fallen to about 22 per cent – well below their baseline.
This was an observational study, which means it can’t answer whether the technology caused the decline in performance. There could be other explanations for the effect: for example, doctors performed about double the number of colonoscopies after the AI tool was introduced compared with before, which might have meant they paid less attention to each scan.
But experts said the fact that there is a de-skilling effect is hardly unexpected. This phenomenon is well-documented: pilots, for instance, undergo special training to brush up on their skills in the age of autopilot.
“I think the big question is going to be: So what? Is that important?” said Robert Wachter, chair of the medicine department at University of California.






