Bold plan to create seniors mega city on peninsula

LONDON: It is a bold plan to turn a peninsula into a sprawling 4,300 home mega oasis for retirees.

South Sydney residents have blasted plans for a “megadevelopment” near them, saying it will “ruin” a famous family hotspot – and it’s even got Dick Smith riled up.

Besmaw Pty wants to build 4300 homes next to Captain Cook’s landing spot on the Kurnell Peninsula, saying it will to boost local housing stock and pump an extra $251 million per year into NSW’s economy.

The proposal comes after the NSW government recommended a radical rezoning of the area. The state government took over the application process from Sutherland Shire Council in 2024.

Besmaw Pty, which is owned by the Holt family, wants to turn an old sand quarry and surrounding scrubland into a retiree oasis with several blocks between two and 12 storeys high and a mini town centre replete with supermarkets, restaurants, medical facilities and an “artisan” quarter. Homes are expected to built in stages over 20 years.

The plans also include 240 affordable homes, 30 social dwellings, and dedicating half of the 210ha site to open spaces like 2km of beach front, three district parks and nine local parks. Besmaw says its proposal, if approved, could draw in thousands of jobs.

But locals say the swanky new suburb, which is being called Bidhinja Beach, is nothing but a “cash cow” for the Holt family.

Roisin Heidenreich, 40, said the development was “disappointing”.

“Don’t they think they’ve put up enough buildings here in Cronulla? I’ve lived here my whole entire life. My parents have been here for 53 years and the way it’s changing, it’s really disappointing, just so these corporations can make money,” the lifelong Cronulla resident told said.

Kurnell resident Joanna Hunter, 51, said she wasn’t “thrilled” by the proposal.

“We’ve been going out to the beach and, I suppose, where the development is, for 40 years. We used to swim and play in the sand hills and now they’re gone and now the lovely atmosphere at the beach, which we locals all love, will now be taken away.”

Fellow Kurnell resident, Chloe Gould, 20, said the development was a cash grab. She wants Captain Cook Drive – the main road in and out – upgraded before any construction takes place.

“There’s always been talk of having a ferry from Kurnell and there’s always been talk of getting a tram or getting a train but nothing’s ever been done and I think it’s just cheap words,” Ms Gould said.

“I’m all for more housing but I think that this is just a lot of people making a lot of money. “It’s under the guise of more housing but it’s not meaningful to my generation or people that are actually wanting to enter the market.”

Mark Forrest, 46, wants more homes built, but doesn’t think Kurnell is the right place. He said roads, electricity and sewerage networks are already at breaking point.

“We had a car fire out here on the road the other day and it blocked everybody for almost two hours, in and out. When we have floods out here, the sewer system is unable to handle it, so that would need to be upgraded,” he said.

“We have had blackouts here over the last 12 months, multiple times.

“There’s a lot of infrastructure that needs to be updated before any of that gets considered.”

Others said they were concerned about the impact on the local environment and biodiversity.

According to consultants hired by Besmaw, the threat to animal life and local infrastructure would be minimal. The report said some of the site holds little ecological value because it’s located on a sand quarry.

The report also suggested the development would not lead to increased flooding. Besmaw has promised to upgrade roads, sewers, water and power infrastructure as well as build community assets such as parks, playing fields and the surf club.

It’s also promised to widen Captain Cook Drive from two to four lanes at no expense to the government or local community but stressed this won’t happen until it raises the funds through the sale of properties on Bidhinja Beach.

Duncan McComb, the boss of The Holt Estate 1861, said the land at Kurnell has been subject to “a lot of misunderstanding and myths” over the years.

“The Planning Proposal and the supporting documents provide an evidence and fact-based foundation for what we have proposed for our land at Kurnell,” Mr McComb said.

“Bidhiinja Beach will be a model for a modern beachside community, with jobs, homes and services all within easy reach, set amongst vast areas of beautiful natural open public space.

“Our proposal has been through an exhaustive process over many years, evolving and incorporating feedback from experts, agencies, government and the community. The result is the best possible balanced outcome for everyone.”

But not everyone is opposed.

Local retiree Geoff Young said the site was an industrial wasteland which desperately needs a makeover.

He said: “[Building more homes] is essential. It’s just a matter of where they’re built. Kurnell isn’t a bad location. Some developments are far away and people have to travel a long way for work. Kurnell is reasonably accessible. It’s as good a place as any.”

For Millennials like Andrew Whale, new homes can’t come quick enough.

“There is definitely a need for housing. For young people it’s hard to get into the market,” he said.

“Things are going through the roof and rents are going up. It’s starting to sting.”

Mum-of-two Denise Faggione, 45, said she supports more homes being built but fears it could ruin Kurnell’s reputation as a family hotspot.

“I have my concerns. I feel it’s a nice place to go with the family. It’s quiet and you have the nature. How much will that change? How much will it affect the environment?” she said.

Others, who did not want to be named, said the area desperately needed more housing.

According to Besmaw’s consultant, Bidhinja Beach will also provide seniors living spaces and residential aged care facilities.

Kaiya Madden, 19, said more affordable housing was needed over “big apartment buildings” for retirees.

“Younger people at the moment are struggling to find affordable housing and just to find just a big retirement community there might add to the pressure of finding affordable housing for younger people,” she said.

Meanwhile, the project evoked a furious response from entrepreneur Dick Smith, who said that Aussies were being forced to “live like termites or battery chickens”.

He claims an influx of immigrants has caused house prices to spike and called for a cap of 70,000 people to be let into the country every year.

“The time our kids could play outside and play with Aussie dirt, that will be gone forever,” he said.

“[Homes] are being replaced with high rises.”

It comes as Cronulla’s median house price skyrocketed by 56 per cent between 2015 and 2025, according to real estate agency Matt Black Property. Realestate.com.au shows in April this year, the median house price in Cronulla was an eye-watering $3.425 million.

Meanwhile, rents are now $1385 a week – a jump from the roughly $900 a week in 2021. According to property data outlet HTAG, affordability is “extreme” in Cronulla with homeowners taking 117 years on average to have outright ownership.

Though cheaper, Kurnell is still considered out of reach for many first-time homebuyers. According to HTAG, the typical house price in Kurnell jumped 8 per cent year-on-year and now costs just shy of $2.1 million.

Corey Bell, who runs Cronulla Real Estate, said it will be a while before house prices drop.

“As the local agent, my job is to understand what this means for property owners and buyers in the area, not to campaign for or against it. What I can say is that the market will respond to certainty, infrastructure, and timing, all of which are still unresolved,” he said.

“Supply does influence affordability in theory, but 4300 homes delivered over 20 years is a very different story to a sudden oversupply.

“What the local community is interested in is what’s happening with Captain Cook Drive and other infrastructure. The infrastructure question has to be resolved before anyone can make meaningful predictions about price impacts across the Shire.”

According to NSW Government Planning, the site will include tourism accommodation, community facilities, walking tracks and a surf lifesaving club. Building heights could range between 3.5 metres and 44 metres.

It is one of nearly 70 state-led rezonings underway across NSW to unlock a pipeline of more than 236,000 homes and 167,000 jobs.

A spokesperson for the NSW’s Department of Planning, Housing and Infrastructure (DPHI) said: “The Kurnell Peninsula rezoning proposal aims to unlock up to 4300 new well-located homes, including up to 240 affordable homes, as part of a staged development of the area over the next 20 years.

“Before accepting the proposal into the State Assessed Rezoning pathway, the Department required the proponent to undertake a rigorous technical assessment and address a range of infrastructure, environmental and affordability conditions.

“The proposal is now open for community feedback, and we encourage all members of the community to have their say. All submissions will be carefully considered in the assessment of the proposal.”

The proposal has been peer reviewed and backed by NSW Department of Climate Change, Energy, and the Environment and Water’s chief scientist. The proposal also incorporates technical measures to manage stormwater drainage and protect water quality in surrounding reserves throughout the site’s rehabilitation and staged development.

A spokesperson for Sutherland Shire Council said the development would represent the single biggest residential build in the Shire since the 1980s.

They said: “While Council is not responsible for the final decision, we will be preparing a formal submission on this project. Council’s final submission to the planning proposal will be considered at an upcoming Council meeting. Council will also continue working with the applicant to negotiate a Planning Agreement focused on infrastructure delivery and long‑term community benefit, should the proposal proceed.

“Council recognises the significance of this project to all Sutherland Shire residents and is encouraging our local community to have their say. Council will continue to actively advocate on matters of critical importance to the community, including transport capacity and safety, environmental protections, emergency service access, compatibility with surrounding land uses, and the timely delivery of essential community infrastructure.”