Build-to-rent developers target single women over 50 market
LONDON: Build-to-rent developers are increasingly espying the single women over 50 market, to anchor new projects.
A new privately funded build-to-rent development in Melbourne’s eastern suburbs includes 33 affordable units that it has made available to qualifying tenantsat below-market rates without requiring a public subsidy.
Developer Local’s 425-unit Box Hill project was able to offer the apartments at a 25.1 per cent discount to market rates through housing provider Storey Residential through measures including lower taxes and a lower bank interest rate, Local co-founder Dan McLennan said.
The success of the project stands in contrast to the federal government’s $10 billion Housing Australia Future Fund which, beset by delays and problems, had delivered just 1432 homes almost halfway into its five-year program to deliver 40,000 affordable and social rental homes.
But such projects can’t replace HAFF altogether. While the business model underpinning Local Box Hill shows an additional way to develop affordable rental housing, it depends on specific conditions, including location and the price of land. In addition, a commercial build-to-rent development could only support a limited number of below-market-rent apartments, he said.
“It’s a HAFF-adder rather than a HAFF-killer,” McLennan said.
“There is obviously a limit to how many dwellings we can offer at a discounted rent off the back of that financial support from our bankers. On the flip side, we’re able to provide outcomes in a mixed tenure building that isn’t all affordable. It also enables people to potentially move one day from being in the affordable stock into a market product without actually leaving the building.”
Australia needed various solutions to build its stock of affordable rental housing, but it also needed to be clear about the models that were most effective as ultimately all below-budget housing was subsidised in one form or another, said affordable housing industry veteran Michael Lennon.
“Experimentation is a very good thing and especially innovation from the private market is to be encouraged in every way we can,” said Lennon, a former chief executive of provider Housing Choices Australia and now the industry chair in housing and planning at Adelaide University.
“I would be loath to say there’s a silver bullet that says this can be done by the market without government subsidy,” he said. “It’s a zero-sum game.”
The biggest hurdle with affordable rental housing is to bridge the revenue gap between what a lower-income tenant can pay and the return an investor or project owner needs to meet their commercial obligations.
Even with a limit to the number of rental homes in the wider build-to-rent project, location was important, McLennan said. In areas such as the inner city or prestige suburbs where rents were high, it would be harder to fill the 25 per cent gap without an explicit subsidy, he said.
“When we start looking at more and more suburban locations, like Box Hill, and other types of markets, it gets easier to do,” he said.
That project’s subsidy comes from a combination of factors. By partnering with Storey, a housing provider that Local’s directors founded with the aim of turning it into an independent entity, the project tapped the land tax exemption for the subsidised rental units.
As a not-for-profit entity, Storey also gets a credit for the GST it pays on inputs such as building materials, as well as for ongoing costs such as maintenance.
National Australia Bank provided a lower – undisclosed – interest rate that reduced financing costs. Local’s operating model was to make the building’s so-called stabilised rental level 97 per cent, rather than the industry standard 96 per cent, McLennan said.
“One percentage point of this project would be four apartments, so you’re talking about over $80,000 to $100,000 a year of income,” he said.
Unlike HAFF funding, which is guaranteed for 25 years, Local’s affordable housing provision is modelled for only 15 years.
“As a rule, you’re talking about programs that are time-limited, not forever and ever,” McLennan said.
The development also includes eight social homes – leased to mostly single women aged over 50 – and eight specialist disability accommodation units for qualifying residents, with National Disability Insurance Scheme subsidies to the SDA units effectively offsetting the reduced rent from low-income tenants in the social homes.
Local and Storey also co-operated to develop 13 affordable units in a separate 477-unit project in inner north-western Melbourne’s Kensington.
“For us Local is part of a case study,” Storey chairperson Queenie Tran said.
“We want to demonstrate this can work and we want to be able to connect with other organisations that are working in the BTR space that do want to offer something affordable.”
The two-tower project, funded by North American pension funds and co-funded by Local (in which Macquarie has a majority stake) has an end value of $350 million.
Weekly market rents in the building – which includes a coworking space, lounge area and private rooms for activities including Mahjong – were set at a 10 per cent premium to the wider Box Hill market, start at $690 for an unfurnished one-bedroom apartment, $765 for a two-bedroom apartment and $1220 for a three-bedroom apartment.
The project was developed by Jeff Xu’s Golden Age, which originally acquired the site intending to create for-sale apartments. But in a worsening market, Local repurposed it for build-to-rent. Golden Age retained ownership of a 13,000-square-metre Sky Square retail and food court precinct in the buildings’ podium.
“Partnering with Local was the right outcome for the residential component, while Golden Age remained focused on delivering a high-quality mixed use precinct for the local community,” Xu said.






