Babylon Health director plans ambitious UK expansion
LONDON: The rise of online GP consultations in the NHS has divided the opinion of health sector-insiders. Critics condemn the threat to traditional practices and risk of harming vulnerable patients, while proponents praise their convenience and cost savings.
Babylon Health has been the focal point of many of these debates. The London-based startup is best known as the provider of GP at Hand, an app that offers AI-powered diagnoses and online consultations with doctors that is currently available to anyone who lives or works within 40 minutes of five affiliated London clinics.
The service has grown rapidly since it launched in November 2017. Around 48,000 people have now registered with GP at Hand, making it one of the 10 biggest general practices in the country and it recently gained approval to be rolled out in Birmingham. Babylon has ambitious plans for nationwide NHS adoption, but critics worry about the effectiveness of its treatment and its impact on the NHS.
Doctors have warned that it is disrupting regular NHS services and risking patient safety and Babylon has also had run-ins with regulators. In 2017, the company tried and failed to prevent the publication of a Care Quality Commission (CQC) report that found “the service was not providing safe, effective, or well-led services but was providing caring and responsive services”.
Paul Bate, Babylon’s director of NHS services and a former executive director of strategy at the CQC, is confident these concerns have now been addressed. He argues that the system facilitates, rather than replaces doctor-patient interaction.
“We know that something like 90 percent of GP appointments can be safely carried out without the need for the GP and the patient to be in the same room,” Bate said from deep within the bowels of London’s cavernous Printworks, the venue for Privatar’s In:Confidence conference last week.
“That’s much better for the person using the service because they don’t have to travel and it’s also great for the GPs. It’s a better experience for them. Now, there are exceptions. It’s digital first, not digital only. If you’re a woman who needs a cervical smear for cancer screening, then that is a face-to-face appointment straight away, and there is zero point in us doing anything digital for taking blood, for example. But the vast majority of the time, you can do things digitally, so we ask. That’s the model.”
Babylon has already attracted supporters in high places. Health secretary Matt Hancock controversially endorsed GP at Hand specifically in a September 2018 interview, describing it as a “revolutionary” service that should be “available to all, not based on their postcode”.
His comments followed reports that NHS England had blocked Babylon’s efforts to offer services in Birmingham. The plan included a physical practice in the city but keeping the host service in London, which raised concerns that users of GP at Hand wouldn’t receive invitations to national screening programmes as they would be sent to the right address.
Hancock responded by calling for the NHS to change its rules to help the likes of Babylon develop digital solutions and navigate an often bureaucratic and suspicious path into public healthcare provision. NHS England has since retracted its objections, giving Babylon the green light to expand to the UK’s second city. Bate believes having a health secretary with a self-professed “unsurpassable enthusiasm” for technology could benefit Babylon’s plans to expand its NHS offering.
”As the secretary of state says, if there are barriers to integration or to innovation, the right answer is to take down those barriers,” said Bate. “So we were really excited that we were able to expand out beyond London. To have the largest practice in the country, even though it only serves one city currently, just shows the scale of interest there is. It will not be for everybody, but the point is choice.
“Now that we have been enabled to go live in Birmingham – and we very much hope and expect other cities to follow quickly – that’s a really positive statement, from the government and from the NHS as a whole, that it wants to see innovative providers of safe healthcare services like Babylon offering their services, and then let people choose.”
The expansion to Birmingham is just the start of Babylon’s NHS ambitions. The company claims that scores of practices have expressed interest in offering GP at Hand to patients, while healthcare journal HSJ reported in September 2018 that Babylon was speaking to 17 CCGs about its digital services and planning to extend its GP partnership into Southampton and Leeds.
Babylon is entering a potentially lucrative market. The virtual consultation market will grow from 19.7 million consultations in 2014 to 158.4 million by 2020, according to market intelligence firm Tractic. It has also received significant backing from NHS England, which announced in November 2017 that it would contribute £45 million over three years towards the costs for online consultation systems for GPs.
Critics worry that this investment isn’t going to the right place. Digital services typically appeal younger, healthier users than sick, elderly patients with more complex and costly healthcare issues, leaving the NHS with less funding for people with greater needs.
Bate is keen to reassure NHS organisations that Babylon Health won’t disrupt their services.
“I would assure them that it’s great care for patients,” he said. “That’s the starting point: clinically safe, effective, high-quality experiences for the people using the services. If I go back to 1948, when a leaflet dropped through every family’s door – and it genuinely did, at the inception of the NHS – and on the front page of that leaflet, there is a box and in that box, it says ‘one: choose your doctor’.
“It’s a very explicit answer, because right from the very beginning of the NHS that has been part of the offer, to choose your general practice. And that’s enshrined in law. So I don’t start from the point of saying does this or doesn’t this disrupt the existing practices, but I start with what’s the best way to get great healthcare to many people and do it in a way that the NHS feels comfortable and safe about a taxpayer-funded service.”






