Vitamin B12 injections in older adults unnecessary

TORONTO: It is well known that vitamin B12 supplementation can be administered to most people with daily pills or parenterally through periodic injections with no difference in hematologic or neuropsychiatric complications. Silverstein et al published a retrospective cohort study utilizing administrative data bases in Ontario, Canada as a research letter attempting to demonstrate the prevalence and impact of inappropriate parenteral B12 injections in those persons 65 and older. Interestingly, they defined inappropriate parenteral supplementation when it was administered to those with a serum B12 level of ≥ 221 pmol/L. Utilizing that methodology, in part utilizing charges for a physician visit and cost of supplies, they estimated that more than CAD$45 million in expenditures could potentially be avoided if these were switched to oral medications.

While I agree that there are many cases where parenteral B12 can be replaced by daily oral supplementation, by the nature of this being published in letter format with limited space to describe methodology in detail, it is not clear, or at least to me, why they chose a level of 221 pmol/L as a cutoff. For one thing, it is well known that many with B12 deficiency at a cellular level can have low-normal vitamin B12 blood levels and testing serum methylmalonic acid levels may be more sensitive to detect B12 deficiency. Furthermore, it is not apparent in forming their economic analysis, whether all patients came in to the office to receive injections as opposed to being taught to administer it to themselves, and if they did report to the clinic, whether they were charged for a physician visit or nursing visit. They additionally did not describe how they were able to document malabsorption, where perhaps parenteral B12 may be indicated, through the methodology employed. They also deemed it inappropriate if no vitamin B12 level was obtained within a year prior to starting vitamin B12. Some patients might have had low vitamin B12 historically more than 1 year prior and for some reason did not return until much later to receive therapy. I could even envision cases wherein patients with certain maladies (dysphagia, dementia, psychiatric disease, etc.) who cannot reliably take daily supplementation might benefit from monthly or every 3 month injections rather than daily oral supplementation. While I find the authors’ attempts laudatory and I do believe oral supplementation is underused, I question the validity, but not the veracity, of their findings.