Court hears carer burnout run as legal defence

CHICAGO: A court is being asked to accept carer burnout as a defence in a murder trial.

Lorraine Smith pleaded guilty to having murdered her granddaughter Kalis Smith, 13, on March 15, 2019, in Whanganui.

Lorraine Smith was a caregiver under pressure, overwhelmed and burnt out. She murdered her granddaughter and offered no excuse.

Again, it was all too much. The Whanganui teacher aide, known as “Nan” to many, sat hunched and weeping in the dock as her crime was told.

She had lured her 13-year-old granddaughter into the sleepout and wrapped a necktie around her throat. She had tugged as Kalis fought, afterward placing a finger over the girl’s nose to check if she was breathing.

Smith, 59, was handed down a compassionate sentence of 12-years’ imprisonment with a minimum term of six years at the Wellington High Court on Wednesday.

Murderers rarely escape a life sentence, and Smith’s “sparingly applied” term of imprisonment was lessened by tragedy.

Her grandchildren had mental health problems, and her own children had serious disabilities, including one son who had died since Smith went into custody for the crime.

Smith had been treated for depression and situation anxiety most her life, Judge Francis Cooke said.

“In the six months leading up to the offence, her mental health deteriorated, triggered by her grandson’s situation and the loss of her own father. She became overwhelmed, suffered from what is described as “carer burnout”: severe emotional, physical and mental exhaustion.”

“In interviews she presented as devastated and overcome with remorse for her actions.”

According to figures compiled for the Homicide Report, a data project investigating why New Zealanders kill, Kalis was the first young teenager to be killed by a maternal caregiver since 2004.

Kalis, pronounced Ka-lees, was Smith’s youngest grandchild, who she raised from the age of 5 months.

She had a happy childhood, the court heard, but their relationship became fraught after she turned 11 years old, began to self-harm, and had suicidal tendencies.

Kalis was killed in a sleepout at their Niblett St, Whanganui, home on March 15. Smith and her granddaughter had argued throughout the early evening, a police summary said, and Kalis threatened to run away.

After an initial argument, where Smith was heard saying “You want to die anyway, don’t you?”, Kalis was asked to help her close windows in a sleepout. Smith grabbed a neck tie as they left the house.

Kalis was wearing the hood up on her sweatshirt, and from behind Smith pulled it over her face and then to the side, wrapped the tie around Kalis’ neck and held it as tight as she could.

Police said Kalis struggled and fought back but Smith was stronger and when Kalis fell to her knees. Smith pulled her back and left her lying on the sleepout floor.

She drove to the hospital, phoned her son, who was Kalis’ father, told him she had done something. Smith then rang 111 and said that she had killed her granddaughter. She then took an overdose of anti-depressant medication and went into the hospital and told staff what had happened.

She told police there was no excuse for what she had done.

“She said she’d had enough of the arguing and the victim’s attitude, and wanted everything to stop,” police said.

Her family had urged her to reconsider a guilty plea, which came a week after the crime. Whānau, community leaders and prisoner advocates all attempted to persuade the grandmother to seek a charge of manslaughter.

Former MP Liz Gordon, president of Pillars, an organisation that helps the families of prisoners, contacted Smith in Rimutaka Prison after reading about the case.

But it’s understood Smith has told them she was going to plead guilty and “be done with it”.

In court on Wednesday, Cooke spared her from a life jail term. The law says that a person convicted of murder should be sentenced to life imprisonment unless that was clearly unjust due to the circumstances of the offence or the offender.

He said Smith had been overwhelmed, but the vulnerability of Kalis and an element of premeditation meant he had to impose a minimum term greater than the one-third she would otherwise have to serve before being considered for parole.

“You have had an extremely difficult life, and been required to carry a heavy burden. In the end the circumstances overwhelmed you and you took the life of one of those you had committed to care for,” he said.

Grandparents Raising Grandchildren chief executive Kate Bundle said the case had highlighted the “extreme pressure” some people could be under caring for their grandchildren.

In many cases children being raised by grandparents were not from typical “well-adjusted” backgrounds. The organisation’s data suggested at least 41 per cent of those children had a diagnosed psychological disorder of some kind.

“They usually have some kind of trauma … There’s no respite – unless people in the wider family can help, [grandparents are] left having to do everything.”

Fiona Guy Kidd QC of Bridgeside Chambers said non-life sentences in murder cases were not unique but “sparingly applied … in appropriate cases”. In this case it appeared both compassionate and appropriate.

“Through the years there have probably been less than 10 such cases,” Guy Kidd said.

“It seemed quite clear to me that she will be serving her own sentence … It’s a tragedy for everyone.”

The tragedy was apparent in court, as family members in the public gallery shared tears with “Nan”.

Smith’s lawyer, Peter Brosnahan, said the grandmother would fall asleep every night, and wake up every morning, knowing what she had done.