Health worker wins misconduct hearing with psychological defence

MELBOURNE: A health worker has defeated a misconduct charge by running the defence that the hearing triggered a psychological injury.

In Srdjan Peric v the State of New South Wales (NSW Health Pathology), Arbitrator William Dalley of the Workers Compensation Commission of New South Wales considered whether:

  • the worker had suffered a psychological injury
  • the worker was entitled to compensation.

The worker, Srdjan Peric, worked for the employer,NSW Health Pathology. On 2 March 2016 the worker was called into a meeting and told he had been found guilty of misconduct. The worker suffered a psychological injury as a result.

The worker claimed compensation, which the employer denied, and the case was brought to court.

The worker had suffered a previous psychological injury at work on 19 April 2015. At 1.30pm on the day of his new injury, the worker was ordered to attend a 3.30pm meeting about his previous injury. The worker attended the meeting alone.

The meeting was about the accusations the worker made concerning the cause of his injury. At the meeting the worker was told his claims had been investigated and found to be vexatious. The worker was told he was being fired for misconduct and was escorted from the workplace.

The worker had an emotional reaction to the meeting and visited his doctor, who diagnosed him with a psychological injury. The worker was off work for a year, using up his leave and taking unpaid leave before ceasing work entirely.

The worker argued he should be paid for his unpaid leave and given reasonable medical costs.

In deciding the case, Arbitrator Dalley found that the worker had established his claim. Arbitrator Dalley ordered the employer to pay the worker compensation.