Medical specialist misinterprets instructions in injury claim

MELBOURNE: A support worker in the home care sector claims a mistake was made in assessing her injury.

In Cathy Janine Hilder v the Secretary of New South Wales Department of Family and Community Services, Arbitrator William Dalley of the Workers Compensation Commission of New South Wales considered whether:

  • the AMS had made an error
  • the assessment was based on incorrect criteria
  • the assessment contained a demonstrable error.

The worker, Cathy Janine Hilder, worked as a support worker for the employer, the Department of Ageing, Disability and Home Care. On 20 May 2017 the worker noticed pain in her lower back while helping a client. She claimed compensation and was referred for assessment by an authorised medical officer (AMS).

On 17 April 2019 the worker was assessed as having a 12 per cent whole person impairment, which was reduced by half due to a pre-existing condition. The worker appealed this assessment.

The worker had experienced prior back pain. However the worker had been working for the employer since around 1992. The worker argued that her condition had developed over time due to the nature of her work. The worker argued that the AMS had failed to follow the instructions issued by the court to consider her injury a long-term injury.

The employer argued that the AMS had correctly assessed the worker’s injury as having occurred on 20 May 2017.

In deciding the case, Arbitrator Dalley reviewed the original instructions and found that the AMS had misinterpreted them. Arbitrator Dalley altered the assessment to reflect that fact, finding that the worker had suffered a 12 per cent impairment with no reduction.