New study focuses on overhauling hospitals for nurse wellbeing

MELBOURNE: Hospitals will be supported to redesign their systems and ways of working to tackle nurse burnout and stress, under a ground-breaking four-year study.

The first-of-its-kind project will see chosen hospitals implement the principles of the Magnet Recognition Programme, an international accreditation scheme that recognises nursing excellence in healthcare organisations.

Run by the accreditation wing of the American Nurses Association, the scheme is based on research showing that creating positive work environments for nurses leads to happier and healthier staff and the delivery of safer patient care, in turn improving recruitment and retention.

Among the key pillars of Magnet are transformational leadership, shared governance and staff empowerment, exemplary professional practice within nursing, strong interdisciplinary relationships and a focus on innovation.

The new study – called Magnet4Europe – is being directed by world-renowned nursing professor Linda Aiken, from the University of Pennsylvania in the US, and Walter Sermeus, professor of healthcare management at Katholieke Universiteit Leuven in Belgium.

Funding of €4m has been provided by the European Union through the Horizon 2020 programme for the project to be carried out in five nations: Belgium, UK, Germany, Ireland, and Sweden.

Nursing workforce professor Jane Ball from the University of Southampton is heading up the UK arm of the programme, with support from an expert team including her colleague at the university, Professor Peter Griffiths.

Nurse academic and Royal College of Nursing president Anne Marie Rafferty is also involved on a Europe-wide scale.

Professor Ball explained that Magnet4Europe was a follow up to the landmark RN4Cast study, which involved many of the same academics and was also funded by the EU.

In what became the biggest nursing workforce study of its kind, the RN4Cast project involved 500 hospitals across 12 European countries, and was carried out between 2009 and 2011.

The study was believed to have been one of the first to find links between the quality of the practice environment and not only patient mortality and satisfaction, but also nurse outcomes.

It found high levels of nurse burnout, intention to quit and dissatisfaction with their job in England. Professor Ball described this finding with the benefit of hindsight as the “writing on the wall” for the nurse staffing crisis now.

“I think that was actually a wake-up call that it isn’t just about how many people you train, but actually the working conditions within our hospitals were not conducive to attracting and keeping nurses,” she said.

“When you look back at the RN4Cast data, what became obvious is that hospitals in England were very far from that Magnet model.

“In the 10 years since, we now have a quite deep seated ongoing national shortage of nurses.”

Under the new project, 60 acute general hospitals, including at least 12 from the UK, will be recruited and supported to introduce the core features of the Magnet programme.

They will each be linked up with an experienced Magnet-recognised hospital to help them redesign their ways of working, staffing and systems through a “learning collaborative”.

Previous studies on this topic have mostly all been observational, in which researchers monitor a situation as it is and look for patterns. But Professor Ball said Magnet4Europe would be experimental.

“We are treating it more like a controlled trial, so that we can deliberately introduce this intervention of adopting these Magnet principles and giving trusts the support they need to rethink the whole way they operate, in order to focus around quality care and success in nursing along those Magnet principles and then look at what difference it makes,” she said.

As well as patient outcomes and cost effectiveness, Magnet4Europe will examine what affect redesigning clinical work environments has on staff mental health, sickness absence and productivity, as well as recruitment and retention rates.

“The idea of adopting Magnet principles is recognising that we’ve got issues around staff wellbeing and mental health, and burnout and stress connected to not only workload, but also the ways and the system of the way we work,” noted Professor Ball.

The study will be carried out in two stages, with one set of hospitals starting the process of implementing the Magnet principles before the other to create a control group for comparison data. The researchers will also look at before and after data for all 60 hospitals involved.

“We recognise nobody wants to be in the ‘never getting the improvements’ club, that’s why it’s called a stepwise trial, in that in the end, they don’t never get it, they just get it later,” said Professor Ball.

Achieving success for nursing “potentially means everybody’s success”, she noted.

“If you can get the care quality right, it means that your nurses are going to be happier and more likely to stay in their jobs and do their best work, and patients are going to get better outcomes. And actually, because some of the dimensions relate to the more general things about how health staff relate together, it is likely to be improving not just things for nurses, but for doctors and other staff,” she said.

The hospitals will not automatically get Magnet status at the end of the programme unless they choose to seek accreditation the normal way, which involves a cost.

While it will be inevitable to some degree, Professor Ball said the team was not seeking to promote any particular accreditation scheme, but rather looking in more depth at what it takes to create positive work environments for nurses and the impact this has.

She said: “The ideal from my point of view is that the research will help us to understand, not should everybody do Magnet, but more when you’re going on a journey of quality improvement and when your goal is improved nursing care and to improve nurse staffing wellbeing, which are really critically important bits?

“Which are the bits that are worth putting most energy and effort into, which are the bits which are really going to pay off in terms of achieving that big goal?

“Because time and energy is limited – we only have limited resource, so that’s something that I think will genuinely help other providers.”

The academics overseeing the project in the five different countries all came together for the first time last week.

They are still in the process of recruiting the hospitals for the project with the intervention work expected to begin in the summer.