Employers being caught up in staff lifestyle injury claims

MELBOURNE: Employers are increasingly being asked to pay for staff injuries incurred via lifestyle choices.

The most recent case involves an insurer for a care provider being asked to pay for an injury triggered by an obesity engendered/altered gait.

In Vladimir Zivanovic v Comcare, Senior Member Dr Stewart Fenwick of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal of Melbourne considered whether:

  • the worker’s conditions were caused by her altered gait
  • the worker’s conditions were work-related
  • the worker was entitled to compensation.

The worker, Vladimir Zivanovic, worked for a government employer. On 3 August 1990 the worker was riding a tram in the course of his employment when he suffered an injury to his right knee. He was paid compensation for permanent impairment from March 2005.

The worker underwent a total knee replacement in 2014, for which he was compensated, and was also granted compensation for hypertension. In this claim the worker sought compensation for injuries to his knees and back.

The employer argued that the worker’s conditions were due to underlying degeneration or his obesity condition. The employer argued that the worker’s current conditions were not work-related. The employer pointed out that the worker had a number of pre-existing conditions, including osteoarthritis, which were contributing to his current health.

The worker argued that if he had not suffered his knee injury he would not have developed his further conditions.

In deciding the case, Senior Member Fenwick noted that the existence of other conditions did not mean that the worker’s work-related injury hadn’t contributed to his current condition.

Senior Member Fenwick examined the medical evidence and found it was likely that the work-related injury, and the operations the worker had undergone afterward, had contributed to the condition of his knee, but not his hypertension. Senior Member Fenwick found that the worker continued to suffer a work-related condition and ordered his entitlement to compensation be reconsidered.