Home care worker wants to stay forever at home

MELBOURNE: A national home care provider is fighting an on-going claim from a home carer who insists her recovery from a back injury needs the rest of her life and a Tribunal is shaping to agree with her.

In Shereen Abdelmalek v Australian Unity Home Care Service Pty Ltd, Arbitrator Cameron Burge of the Workers Compensation Commission of New South Wales considered whether:

  • the worker was entitled to compensation
  • the worker had suffered a permanent impairment
  • the worker was entitled to medical expenses.

The worker, Shereen Abelmalek, worked for the employer, Australian Unity Home Care Services. The worker claimed that she suffered injuries to her spine in the course of her work between September 2016 and February 2018. She received compensation until December 2018, after which the employer decided she had recovered from her condition.
The worker disputed this decision and brought the case to court.

The worker stated that some of her duties involved heavy work, including moving tables and chairs when attending clients at community centres, having to move clients in and out of showers and general lifting, pushing, pulling and carrying.

The worker stated that on 9 October 2017 she felt pain in her back while she moved a foldable table. She visited her doctor but continued working. She felt further pain on 12 February 2018 while moving tables and chairs. She continued working, but as her pain increased she visited a doctor, who sent her for a CT scan. She was off work from 16 to 21 February 2018. She returned with altered duties.

The worker was paid compensation until 7 December 2018. The worker argued she was entitled to further compensation.

The worker’s initial claim was for a distinct injury, which the employer argued had ceased. The worker argued that her new claim was for injuries caused by the nature and conditions of her work.

In deciding the case, Arbitrator Burge examined the evidence and found that the worker had shown she had suffered an injury due to the nature and conditions of her work.

Arbitrator Burge ordered the worker to be sent to an approved medical specialist for assessment, and her claims for medical expenses and weekly compensation to be heard in a further hearing after the assessment.