‘Battle-fatigued’ care-home providers to be private equity target
LONDON: As Covid-19 triggered an unprecedented crisis in nursing homes, “battle-fatigued” small and medium private care providers can become potential targets for large corporations, such as private equity firms.
That’s according to Nadra Ahmed, executive chair of the National Care Association.
“There is an opportunity for those who have the cash to buy out the best in the market. [Providers] are very tired as they can’t see any end to this very long dark tunnel, especially if they are looking at a second wave,” she said.
Ahmed’s organisation represents about 4,000 small and medium enterprises in the sector, which typically have up to 50 beds. At the moment, one of their main concerns, she points out, is financial sustainability, as occupancy rates halved in recent months.
A recent NCA survey of 256 providers found that in June, 2,404 beds were standing empty, while at the same time last year, there were 1,281 vacancies.
The situation reflects the high death toll: in England, 30% of all Covid-19 deaths were recorded in care homes, the latest data from the Office for National Statistics show. Also, many customers are avoiding long-term care facilities, Ahmed said.
“Providers have been delivering care services despite the funding challenges for over a decade at least, any resilience they had in their businesses has been eroded by this virus, and many now face an uncertain future,” she added.
Although more distressed opportunities are likely to emerge in the second quarter, so far European private equity firms haven’t made any major moves. In the first six months, the industry concluded 10 deals in nursing homes, home care, and assisted living niche segments, according to data provider Preqin. The number of transactions is the same recorded in the first half of last year.
Similarly, buyout firms exited seven investments this year, just slightly below the 10 assets sold in mid-year 2019 in Europe.
William Laing, a healthcare economist at consultancy LaingBuisson, explained why PE firms are not interested in bargain hunting: “There will undoubtedly be some distress sales, and maybe some will be picked up by PE-backed operators, but many financially distressed homes will not be suitable for corporate portfolios and most private equity does not have an appetite for turnarounds.”
He added the impact of the pandemic varied across the care industry, and “those operators who have been fortunate enough, or careful enough, to avoid Covid infections have not seen their occupancy fall and are doing extremely well.”
Official figures don’t specifically break out how PE-backed homes weathered the crisis, but some experts warn their ownership model may be challenged. More oversight, or tougher, costlier regulations are a likely scenario in the aftermath of the pandemic.
Several PE-owned nursing home chains in the UK have suffered Covid outbreaks, while some have also been criticised in the past by authorities for providing poor quality of care. In the US, research has linked PE-ownership to an overall decline in the standard of care in residential nursing homes.
“It appears that there is a general change in the attitude towards private equity firms in the healthcare sector. People are more hesitant and sceptical now,” says Florien Kruse, a health policy researcher at Radboud University Medical Center in the Netherlands.
Kruse also works with an ILTC team set up by the London School of Economics to monitor the impact of the pandemic on the long term care sector.
She believes there should be greater transparency over the ownership of any firms receiving public contracts, along with stronger scrutiny by commissioners. “Investors in health care services should not be motived purely by financial interest – they should also contribute to financial sustainability and quality of care in the sector,” Kruse added.






