Boomers challenge retiree village shareholders over capital gains
WELLINGTON: The boomers being sought as the new generation clients of retirement villages are arguing they won’t move in unless they can earn the capital gains derived from their occupancy.
The impasse now threatens both the village viability and dividend stream for traditional shareholdres.
Through each phase of their life cycle, boomers seem to have opposed anything that might prevent them having it easy. In the 1960s some protested against the Vietnam War, refusing to do their bit against totalitarianism, while their parents had suffered through World War II.
They went to university for free, paid for through high taxes. Then, upon starting work, they seemed to realise taxes were a terrible thing, voted for a succession of neoliberal policies that cut government spending, and made the generations after them pay for tertiary education.
Then there is the present housing crisis, a product of many factors, some of which include the perennial boomer not-in-my-backyardism against urban intensification, or new suburbs in general.
There appeared to be no such opposition when they were young and buying their first homes in new developments. It is only now, that they are settled, that our towns and cities can be declared full.
And finally, in 2021, enough of them have reached retirement age that some have turned their attention to reforming another sector of society that just isn’t doing enough to make life effortlessly easy for them: retirement villages.
Retirement villages have been around for decades in New Zealand, along with their licence to occupy model. Residents pay for the right to occupy their house or unit in the village, but many do not own it.
In return, they have access to the village amenities and don’t need to worry about paying insurance or rates. There is stability and security, and a sense of community with their neighbours of a similar age and outlook.
The downside to this model is that residents are not entitled to any of the capital gains their unit may have attained during their occupation.
While this may not have been an issue in the early 2000s, when capital growth in housing was more moderate, in 2021 it has become impossible to ignore.
Together with the seemingly increasing sense of boomer entitlement, the result has been a promised investigation by the Government into the way retirement villages operate, with a view to sharing some of these capital gains with owners.
What seems to be missing from the raft of articles and opinion pieces that have emerged in recent weeks around this topic, is emphasis on one simple truth: That not one resident living in a retirement village in New Zealand is obliged to live there.
Yes, believe it or not, people choose to live in retirement villages.What’s more, they’re even made aware of the fact they don’t own the property. It’s in something called the terms and conditions.
Ryman, Summerset, Arvida, and the like aren’t rounding up the elderly and putting them on trains to their horribly oppressive aged-care camps. Some of these people are making the inquiries themselves, making the purchase with capital freed up from the sale of their mortgage-free homes.
As a shareholder in New Zealand’s listed retirement village operators, both directly and through index funds, I applaud their resistance to sharing capital gains with residents.
The capital gains should belong to investors, like myself, who take on the risks of property maintenance, insurance, and further development.
If boomers crave capital gains so much, they should just sit tight in their present homes, the median price of which has increased $200,000 in the last year alone.
However, I would much rather they sell up and move to their nearest retirement village, while the younger generations invest heavily into the publicly-traded companies that operate these facilities.
It’s one, small way to claw back a little of the wealth that they seem to have so artfully concentrated amongst themselves, after a lifetime of appearing to have it easy.
Who knows? We might even get a house deposit out of it.






