Court rules against healthcare provider over stressful work practices
MELBOURNE: A court has ruled that a healthcare provider must pay for an injury or condition exacerbated by stressful work practices.
In Evan Michaels v Kincare Health Services Pty Ltd, Arbitrator John Wynyard of the Workers Compensation Commission of New South Wales considered whether:
- the worker was entitled to lump sum compensation
- the worker was entitled to weekly compensation
- the worker had suffered a psychological injury.
The worker, Evan Michaels, worked as a registered nurse and regional manager for the employer, Kincare Health Services. He claimed that on 18 May 2017 he suffered a psychological injury in the course of his work. He claimed compensation, which the employer denied, and the case was brought to court.
The worker stated that on the day of his injury he was severely distressed by the incompetence of the employer. The worker stated that this led to an aggravation of his pre-existing condition of depression.
The worker supplied a statement from his psychologist supporting his claim. The psychologist stated that the worker had seemed happy at work and coping well with his illness until he started work with the employer. From that time, the psychologist stated, the worker became perceptibly more stressed.
The worker stated that although he had long-term depression it had never affected his ability to work before the incident with the employer. The worker stated he had completed several qualifications, including two Master degrees, and coped with a divorce, without having to take days off work for his condition. Following the date of injury, he had experienced a continued incapacity for work.
In deciding the case, Arbitrator Wynyard reviewed the worker’s medical and working history and found that the worker had established his case. Arbitrator Wynyard ordered the employer to pay the worker $1446.31 for between 18 May to 16 August 2018, and $1217.95 from 17 August 2018 onward.






