Dementia sufferers causing fatal injuries to others
MELBOURNE: Warren Leaf died after he was attacked by another care home resident in dementia care.
Warren Leaf was a sheep farmer with a difference. He also loved singing, theatre and writing poetry for his local newspaper.
“When I am just a memory,” went the opening line from his poem titled, You and Me, “and closed eyed you paint the past/take the brush strokes of your mind/and gently touch the highlights/which help to make my memory last.”
Leaf also had the only grand piano in his district and whenever a visiting pianist was touring, he’d invite them over.
“He would put on these concerts and we’d have, like, 150 people in our lounge,” daughter Megan recalls.
But in his final years, Leaf drained away before his family’s eyes as dementia exerted its cruel grip.
He’d wander at night and be found by police, sometimes naked. He’d be belligerent towards his family, accusing them of wanting to lock him up.
In the end, it was his habit of wandering that got him killed.
The 87-year-old walked into the room of another resident in the dementia unit of Carter House rest home in Te Puke in the middle of the night in November, 2015.
A staff member heard his cries and found him on the floor, being kicked in the abdomen by the man whose room he’d entered.
Leaf died three days later of his injuries.
Warren Leaf died after he was assaulted by another resident in a Te Puke rest home. This photo was taken about a year before he died.
Police launched a homicide investigation, but no charges were laid because it was determined the man with dementia who attacked Leaf could not have formed an intent.
A report by the Health and Disability Commissioner found a number of serious failings on the part of Carter House – it had not developed a plan to manage Leaf’s wandering and he was not seen by a doctor for more than 24 hours after the assault.
The home is now under new management.
Megan Leaf, a Te Puke lawyer, says the HDC investigation did not look at the management of her father’s attacker, which she believes was also lacking.
He’d only been in the home a week or two, and had already assaulted another resident, she says.
The man would have been more agitated than usual as he settled into a new environment, she says, yet there was no heightened monitoring.
“Every dementia patient is different … some are incredibly gentle and sing and wander around loving a cuddle … others are violent, you just don’t know until you’ve monitored them for a while what they’re going to be like.”
Leaf fears that if better systems are not put in place, there will be more similar cases.
Dementia is an umbrella term for a range of conditions that cause a decline in mental ability. Alzheimer’s disease is the most common.
About 70,000 Kiwis are living with dementia and that number is expected to almost triple by 2050 as the population ages, according to Alzheimers NZ.
An analysis has found that between 2013 and 2018, there were five occasions where someone died after being assaulted by a person with dementia, sparking homicide inquiries.






