Grandchildren emerging as big winners in generational wealth transfer

LONDON: Grandchildren are the main beneficiaries in the rise of the bank of Nan and Pop.

Dorothy Dukai, 73, is leaving her children out of her will and giving everything to her six grandchildren via a trust.

She figures her four children – aged in their late 30s and 40s – are professionally and financially established so it’s best that the money be used to assist the youngest members of the family, including 19-month-old Basil.

Unless something changes dramatically, he will grow up in a world where eye-watering sums are required to pay off university debts and purchase a home.

A retired manager of a graphic design company, Dukai says her children have agreed to forgo their inheritance, although there are no formal agreements locking them into the decision.

“I have no guarantee that issues will not arise among my children in the future,” she says. “But I’ve said to them, why not have a little something set aside for their children’s future? They know by the time any legal dispute goes through the courts, the estate’s value will be lost in legal fees.”

Dukai is part of a Baby Boomer generation that is the wealthiest in history, and is set to leave an unprecedented amount to families, friends and charities.

According to an analysis by financial services research firm CoreData, $4.9 trillion is set to flow from wealthy Baby Boomers in the next 10 years. Of that, $2.3 trillion will go to their children, $1.7 trillion to charities and other family members, and the remaining $931 billion to grandchildren.

Safewill Legal, an online will company, says the number of wills naming grandchildren as beneficiaries has tripled over the past five years to about 10 per cent, and the share of assets has more than doubled to 12 per cent.

Safewill Legal principal Isabelle Marcarian says some clients skip a generation because they are wary of seeing their “hard-earned savings” become part of a settlement in a child’s divorce or blended family disputes involving stepchildren.

Nicola Powell, chief of research and economics with Domain, a property search company part-owned by Nine, says some grandparents are adopting the ‘giving while living’ approach to help the next generations cope with the rising cost of housing.

significant hurdles” young people face in buying a home today, Powell says.

“When you think about why [the wealth transfer] is skipping a generation here, it’s probably because their own children already have their own home.”

Rate increases have squeezed mortgage holders but provided additional income to people with term deposits, namely self-funded retirees. Financial advisers tell grandparents are increasingly helping out with private school fees, holidays and even everyday living expenses.

Chris Ogilvie, a financial adviser at Invest Blue, says that although most grandparents plan to pass on the bulk of their money to their adult children, they increasingly want to help out with things such as school fees and excursions for the grandkids.

He says transfers often take the form of “co-saving”. That is, if the grandchild has a goal of saving for a car or house, the grandparents will say, “Whatever you save, we will match it.”

“At the end of the day, it’s not about giving money that can be spent or blown on frivolous items, it’s to support things that are going to make an enduring difference to their grandkids,” Ogilvie says.

But if grandparents would prefer to wait until their deaths to pass on wealth, a popular way to protect assets and lower taxes is to create a testamentary trust, says Guy Taylor, a private wealth manager at consultancy BDO.

Such trusts come into effect upon the death of the testator (in this case the grandparent).

Taylor says asset protection and tax benefits have contributed to a fivefold increase in the number of grandparents using testamentary trusts during the past decade.

Rather than leaving assets directly to a beneficiary, they are transferred into a trust and held on behalf of an individual, or group of beneficiaries.

Taylor says a trust can protect assets and reduce the tax payable on distributions. Income can be distributed to children who earn no other income, rather than to adults who might be on high marginal rates.

A testamentary trust can also make loans to a beneficiary, which might be used to buy a house, if permitted by the trust’s deeds. Loan terms can be decided by the trustees and do not have to be on commercial terms.

Trustees, who are responsible for managing the money or assets, retain control over the capital, which could be lost if gifted to a beneficiary.

Consultants say testamentary trusts are suitable for comparatively modest estates of about $500,000 through to the mega-rich. However, some lawyers say they wouldn’t recommend a trust for an estate worth less than $2 million. Their cost depends upon the size of the estate and the complexity of instructions, including the number of beneficiaries. Establishment costs typically range from $3000 to $5000.

There are also ongoing costs from accountants, asset managers and, if needed, professional trustees.
Avoiding legal setbacks

Darryl Browne, a lawyer with Browne Linkenbagh Legal Services, says parents are living longer and often when they die, their children – and likely beneficiaries – already have stable incomes and a home, and have less need for an inheritance.

According to a government analysis, life expectancy is expected to rise to 91 for males and 93 for females by 2050. That means when parents die, their children are likely to be in their late middle-age and their grandchildren in their late teens or early 20s.

A Sydney-based mother of two children, who asked not to be named, says she understands why her mother wants to bequeath her entire estate to her grandchildren.

“It’s her money and assets,” she says. “The grandkids give her their time, effort and love, and she wishes to return it to them. I understand her decision even if it means I’m not included in the will.”

But Browne warns that by the time the parent dies, the children might have developed needs not addressed in the will, such as chronic illness requiring expensive treatment or a costly divorce settlement.

Recent research by ANZ Private Bank has found that about 70 per cent of transfers of intergenerational wealth fail because of dissipating wealth, family conflicts, misaligned family values, delays and bungled execution.

“A child can challenge the parent’s will because courts consider the primary moral obligation of the parent on death is to the children, rather than the grandchildren,” Browne says.

Lawyers warn about the potential for bitter, protracted and expensive legal disputes potentially involving grandparents’ estates, adult children and their spouses, grandchildren and stepchildren from blended families.

Barrister Giles Stapleton, of Selborne Chambers in Sydney, who specialises in the overlap between property and family matters, says grandparents need to carefully plan their wills to reduce the risk of family conflict.

Giles Stapleton, a barrister, says family members should be involved in the decisions to avoid trouble later on. Oscar Colman

“Children might initially support a will that skips their generation in favour of the grandchildren, but later in life become disgruntled, needy or ill and will start a legal action for share,” Stapleton says.

“Depending on the state or territory, a child is likely to have an absolute right to apply to the Supreme Court for a family provisions order, unless they agree to a release of those claims that is approved by that court,” he says.

A family provision order is an application for a share, or larger share, from the estate of a deceased person.

Stapleton recommends that parents discuss any agreement with their children, be clear about what it means for all parties, and ensure that it is fully documented and reviewed by an experienced lawyer.

Suzanne Jones, partner and head of estate planning for Coote Family Lawyers, says these four things are worth considering for anybody planning to leave money to grandchildren.

Timing is everything, particularly if your grandchildren are still young, Jones says. Decide when you would like your grandchild to receive the gift and state that in your will. That way, the executor can pay the gift once the grandchild turns 18, although usually, grandparents prefer that financial gifts be delayed until the grandchildren are a few years older and have had some life experience.

Sometimes financial gifts are left to grandchildren for a specific purpose. For
larger gifts of $100,000 or more, grandparents usually intend for the gift to be used to help a grandchild enter the property market. Smaller gifts may be designed to help pay for education or a car. Make sure you state the purpose of the gift in your will.

Gifts to grandchildren can sometimes cause resentment from others. For
example, if one child has four grandchildren and another has one child, the division of a financial gift might be better given on a per-family basis, rather than a per-grandchild basis, so give this careful thought.

Often grandparents want to cover school fees and ensure they can still contribute to the younger grandchildren’s education after their death. In this case, they may want to include a clause in their wills using a formula for their executor to set aside an amount to equalise gifts to grandchildren, such as $10,000 per year for each year of the remaining secondary school as of the date of their death.