Greens social housing bid fails as regeneration rezoning moves forward

LONDON: An attempt to lock up a regeneration site exclusively for social housing has failed.

At Wollongong City Council’s Monday night meeting, councillors were discussing the rezoning of the Bellambi Point area to allow for Homes NSW to build up to 2500 homes of two to six storeys over the next 20 years.

The council had developed a draft submission to NSW Homes that called for “a higher proportion of social housing and to include a clear commitment to affordable housing”.

The submission didn’t put a number on the amount of social housing, but Greens councillor Deidre Stuart did.

In a proposed amendment, she wanted to see the council call for 50 per cent of social housing.

“In the fourth paragraph of the submission it says council supports the proposed increase in social housing but encourages Homes NSW to consider delivering a higher proportion of social housing,” Cr Stuart said..

“I’m just wondering if we can change that to 50 per cent rather than the 30 per cent that’s already committed.”

She said the 50 per cent target would be “more ambitious” and would reuce the current housing waitlit by one-third.

Supporting the amendment, Greens Cr Kit Docker supported the increase in density at the site.

“Uplift in height and density represents a far more efficient use of land, both for people and the environment,” Cr Docker said.

“At a time when we are facing significant housing pressures, increasing density in appropriate locations is an important part of delivering more homes and improving overall supply.”

He did express concern that the proposal represented a decline in the proportion of public housing at the site.

“This site has historically been a public housing estate, with around 95 per cent of dwellings serving that purpose,” he said.

“Under the state government’s proposal, the proportion dropped significantly all the way down to 30 per cent, fundamentally shifting the purpose of this community.

“In the middle of a housing and homelessness crisis, that represents a fundamental change in the purpose of land.”

Cr Dan Hayes was not in support of the amendment, noting the new “salt and pepper” approach to locating social housing which moved away from the former practice of grouping them in one area.

“Everyone has recognised that the previous approach of clustering public housing or social housing has not worked in the long run,” Cr Hayes said.

“So by increasing the density, by increasing the raw numbers of social housing, but by also increasing the number of private homes, is that salt and pepper approach.

“This amendment seems to be leaning back more to that cluster approach.”

Cr Linda Campbell said she had grown up in public housing and being clustered together wasn’t the right approach.

“We recognised over many years that socially that does not help people growing up in those areas,” Cr Campbell said.

“And you need to have the salt and pepper approach because socially that’s how you allow everyone to live.

“So we’ve finally figured that out, and after years of getting it wrong and creating slums, the state government’s gone, ‘hang on a minute, we can rethink this and do this better’.”

The amendment was put to the vote and lost 9-3, the three Greens councillors voting against it.

The original motion to send the submission to NSW Homes was passed 11-1, with only Cr Docker opposed.