Home carer in injury claim against church charity

LONDON: A home carer is attempting to stick the bill for her carpal tunnel syndrome on her charity employer.

In Mary Coombs v BaptistCare NSW and ACT, Arbitrator Jacqueline Snell of the Workers Compensation Commission of New South Wales considered whether:

  • the worker’s condition was work-related
  • the worker suffered carpal tunnel syndrome
  • the worker was entitled to medical expenses.

The worker, Mary Coombs, worked for the employer, BaptistCare. The worker claimed that she had developed bilateral carpal tunnel syndrome in the course of her work. She asked the employer for medical expenses, which the employer denied, and the case was brought to court.

The worker’s work involved caring for elderly and disabled people in their homes. She worked full time and was on a roster that required her to work every second weekend. She also did overtime when required.

The worker stated that her duties included assisting people with dressing, showering, toileting and putting on compression stockings. She also cleaned and prepared food. The worker stated her duties involved using both of her hands for prolonged, forceful and repetitive actions.

The worker began noticing pain in her wrists and hands in early 2019. She stated this intensified in March 2020. She visited her doctor on 5 May 2020 and began to take days off work due to her condition at around this time. She was on pain medication and was undergoing physiotherapy treatment. She was referred to a specialist on 2 June 2020 and reported her injury to the employer on 6 June 2020. She was assigned nocturnal splints and referred for surgery shortly after.

The employer refused to cover the worker’s surgery. The employer argued that the worker’s condition was not work-related.

In deciding the case, Arbitrator Snell reviewed the medical evidence and found that the worker had established that she suffered carpal tunnel, and that the condition was due to her work. Arbitrator Snell ordered the employer to pay the cost of the worker’s medical treatment.