Industry faces uphill battle in overcoming consumer hesitation
LONDON: Consumers increasingly are familiar with senior living options and even are using artificial intelligence to assist with searches, but the industry is facing a challenge of converting interest into move-ins as the decision-making process is stretching longer for all care and service levels, according to a new report.
The American Seniors Housing Association last week released the “ASHA/ProMatura Consumer Sentiment Report: Spring 2026,” based on 2,400 survey responses from lead lists of four operating companies that are ASHA members, as well as a list of age- and income-qualified adults from data platform Dynata’s internet research panel.
Social connection and lifestyle benefits are increasing interest in the sector, but they aren’t driving decision-making or overcoming hesitation, according to the report. The authors further noted that hesitation is less a result of affordability concerns and more related to perceived value, pricing transparency and trust.
“We’re seeing a more informed and thoughtful consumer than ever before,” Kristen Paris, PhD, ProMatura vice president of market research and lead researcher on the study, said in a statement. “As providers continue to build trust and simplify the decision process, there is strong potential to convert growing interest into future demand.”
Appeal is lackluster
Overall, consumer respondents said they were fully aware of various senior living settings — active adult, independent living and assisted living, and memory care — but the appeal of certain settings is waning compared with results of previous surveys.
Despite the needs associated with moves to assisted living and memory care communities, respondents appropriate for such settings were just as likely to indicate delaying a move-in for three years or longer as were residents considering lifestyle settings of active adult or independent living. Although most senior living segments showed stability in momentum, assisted living stood out with declining move-in intent, which the authors said signals a growing hesitation despite the high-needs nature of the setting.
Just 40% or respondents said they found rental active adult communities appealing. Appeal increased modestly since the last survey, but that change in perception has not translated into action. Decision timelines are long for rental active adult communities, with 63% of respondents indicating that they aren’t eyeing moves for another three or more years.
Active adult communities where units are for purchase fared similarly, with just 37% of respondents finding the concept appealing. Decision timelines were just as long there as with the rental option, with almost 70% saying they expected to move in three or more years.
Familiarity is driving increased engagement for independent living, with perceptions improving slightly over time, as 41% indicated that they find the setting appealing. Intent is higher than active adult, for which 21% expressed the likelihood of a move but two-thirds don’t expect that move to come for another three or more years.
Assisted living is losing its luster, however, according to responses. Only 36% indicated that they found the setting appealing. Compared with previous studies, intent to assisted living move dropped sharply, with fewer respondents indicating a likely move and more shifting to “unsure” or “unlikely,” according to the report. Decision timelines are long as well, with almost 80% of respondents anticipating a move in three years or longer.
Memory care communities had the weakest appeal of all care types among respondents, with only 25% finding the setting appealing. Small declines in appeal and increases in “unappealing” responses suggest growing hesitation or discomfort with the category, according to the authors. Interest remains low, at 26% of respondents expressing the likelihood of a move into memory care and an overwhelming 90% saying they don’t anticipate moving for three years or more.
Cost remained the biggest barrier for active adult, independent living and assisted living, whereas safety and quality of care overwhelmingly dominated concerns among respondents about memory care communities.
Longer decision-making runway
When it comes to the decision-making window, more than half of respondents (51% to 60%) indicated they have been considering a move for less than a year, whereas 41% to 50% said they have been sitting on a decision for two to five or more years, depending on the setting.
Memory care stands out, with the shortest decision-making timeframe; 66% of prospects said they are considering a move within a year. Active adult prospects showed the longest consideration window, with 33% considering a move in three or more years.
Considerations for independent living and assisted living sat in the middle, with about half saying they would be deciding within a year and the rest taking a more extended evaluation, providing opportunities for ongoing nurturing strategies, according to the report authors.
But a “meaningful” segment of respondents remain undecided, with 42% taking two to five years or more to explore options. This uncertainty suggests confusion or lack of clear differentiation in the market among settings, according to the report.
Role of AI is growing in searches
Artificial intelligence is beginning to play a broader role in senior living research, as respondents indicated an openness to using the technology to explore options while preferring to rely on human interaction for final decisions.
AI awareness already is mainstream: 69% of respondents said they are aware of AI tools that help compare products and services, and 35% said they are comfortable using AI to shop for and compare communities. Almost one in 10 consumers reported already having used AI to explore senior living or active adult communities, suggesting strong potential for growth as use cases become clearer.
Digital searches are the leading way consumers first learn about senior living options, according to the report, but across all care/service types, the majority (54% to 61%) have not visited a community website. Most consumers begin their journey independently rather than through healthcare professionals or formal referrals. In-person engagement continues to play a meaningful role in early discovery, with community tours and drop-ins retaining their importance in decision-making.
Overall, however, consumers appear highly reluctant to engage directly with senior living communities, with only 30% to 40% saying they are likely to share contact information. Moving from an anonymous search to sharing contact information represents the most significant friction point in the senior living journey, according to the report.






