Major care provider challenges staff injury ruling

LONDON: A major care provider has gone to court to challenge a staff injury compensation ruling.

In Bupa Care Services Pty Ltd v Amy Jean O’Keefe, Member Catherine McDonald, Dr David Crocker and Dr Michael Davies of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal of New South Wales considered whether:

  • the medical assessment was incorrect
  • the assessment was made using incorrect criteria
  • the worker had suffered a permanent impairment
  • the worker should be reassessed.

The worker, Amy Jean O’Keefe, worked as an assistant in nursing for the employer, Bupa. On 20 January 2017 she was moving a heavy patient when she suffered an injury to her neck and right arm. She later suffered further injury to her right arm when helping a patient out of bed.

The worker received compensation and returned to work on administrative duties. Her employment was terminated in March 2020.

On 17 November 2021 the worker was assessed by a medical assessor as having a 23 per cent whole person impairment. The employer appealed the medical assessment.

The worker suffered limitation in the use of her right arm. The worker had undergone two surgeries on her right arm, leaving scarring.

The medical assessor found that the worker has suffered permanent impairment in her right shoulder, right little finger, brachial plexus and scarring. The employer argued that the medical was in error. The employer argued that any impairment in the worker’s little finger was due to a peripheral nerve injury. The employer also argued that the assessor had incorrectly calculated the percentage of the worker’s impairment and did not apply the correct criteria in making the assessment.

In deciding the appeal, the judges found that the medical assessor had made an error in deciding which criteria to apply. The judges reassessed the worker and found she had suffered a 24 per cent whole person impairment.