Over-50s facing job hunt agony as deemed to old to hire

LONDON: Huw Waters is an unwilling bellwether. When the unemployed marketing director wrote a LinkedIn post about the “silent wall” — his “story of job-hunting at 50 and the unspoken reality of age discrimination” — his intention was merely to “provoke some thought”.

Instead, his frustrated account of applying unsuccessfully for nearly 300 jobs — despite a 25-year career that included senior roles such as head of marketing at Capita, the outsourcing company, and the charity Allergy UK — provoked thousands of responses from similarly aged professionals who said his story mirrored their own.

Waters, 50, has been searching for work for 16 months, during which he has been invited to just four interviews, while 198 companies have not responded to his applications.

“When you’ve built an excellent career, kept your skills sharp, worked for world-class brands, and you still can’t get through the interview door, you have to ask why? For me, the only answer that makes sense is age,” wrote Waters.

He believes that recruiters scanned his work history and assumed he was “too old-school”. Waters said he was “desperate for a permanent role … running very low on money and options. This is the story of countless professionals over 50 who still have so much to give, but are quietly shut out of opportunities.”

Accomplished over-50s job hunters worldwide confirmed the trend. “Rest assured, it won’t get better with the years,” said Johannes Ziegler, a German IT expert. “I’m having the same experience at the age of 60-plus. If the AI won’t [reject me], it’s the recruiter, less than half my age.”

Scott Bauer, a data analyst from the US in his fifties, said that his 161 applications had led to no job offers. He contended that companies were forgetting that his generation’s “deep knowledge is the threads of why things are the way they are, and the how and why things work the way they do, today”. He made a baseball analogy: “Sorry, very accomplished pitcher, we’re signing this high school senior because his team won the state championship and is less expensive.”

About 750,000 Britons aged 50-64 are job-hunting or willing to work, but economically inactive, government figures show. One in eight workers aged 45 and older believes age has been a factor in them missing out on a job or promotion, according to research by the Centre for Ageing Better. Of those, 40 per cent were either explicitly told their age was a factor, or said it was implied.

The rise in the unemployment rate for 50 to 64 year-olds — to 3.1 per cent last month, up from 2.4 per cent 12 months previously — is higher than for any other age group, figures from the Office for National Statistics show. Meanwhile, the number of over-50s claiming benefits recently hit almost two million for the first time, according to the Centre for Social Justice.

Yet older workers say that ageism is left off the agenda when firms consider diversity and inclusion.

Ian Robinson, a quality-control expert whose career includes director roles at Toyota and Philips Healthcare plus 22 years at Honda, has applied unsuccessfully for 49 roles in just the past two months. The 54-year-old is so keen to find work that he has applied for roles specific to his experience in the US, Canada, Europe, Japan, Thailand and India. “I’m free to go anywhere in the world for a job,” he said. “But despite all my experience, I just get turned down.

“I’ve had 21 rejections and the rest just never responded to the long application process. My experience is at director or vice-president of quality level” — checking standards of components or suppliers — “but I’ve dropped down to head of quality or even quality manager roles, and I’m still not getting any offers.”

As most applications involve companies using artificial intelligence to sift through them, Robinson has tried to contact recruiters advertising roles directly. “But I’ve heard nothing back. I’ve also asked for feedback, so I can learn or change my approach, but [I get] silence or a generic ‘we’re going with a candidate more suited to the role’ response. But I’ve been doing the actual role for decades.

“Is it ageism? I’ve just removed my date of birth from my CV, to see if that helps. Previously throughout my career, whenever I’ve managed to get an interview, I’ve got the job. But now I’m struggling to even get a phone call, let alone a Teams interview — there’s no human contact in recruitment.”

Robinson added: “It’s starting to feel a struggle. You start to think, ‘Why am I bothering?’ ”

Katherine Crawshaw, who is running an “Age Without Limits” campaign at the Centre for Ageing Better, confirmed that the tough job market, with soaring numbers of applications per vacancy, was hurting older workers hardest. “When competition for jobs is particularly high, ageist assumptions can be the difference between getting the job and the continuation of a very draining and demoralising job search,” she said.

“It is dispiriting to see the persistence of ill-founded stereotypes about older workers’ ability to work fast, adapt, use technology and develop within their role, when older workers have such potential to tackle skills shortages, help businesses to thrive and grow our national economy.”

Crawshaw called for government employment support services and training to be tailored for people in their fifties and sixties — “to help ensure that older workers who want to work do not fall out of the labour market years before they are ready to retire”.

Paul Sharman falls into that category. His varied CV spans 20 years working in software, including at headhunter Egon Zehnder in California before he moved back to the UK in 2007 and focused on working around his passion: fishing and the outdoors.

But since a six-month contract as bookings manager for a Highlands estate ended in February, “I’ve been constantly applying for jobs. I’ve sent off over 90 applications, but no luck — yet.”

Sharman, 59, added: “I know I can do the jobs, not least as I’ve lots of experience doing them. But each time you hear a ‘no’, or hear nothing at all, it hits you. I think there’s some ageism. Most of my interviews have been with much younger managers. That’s no problem to me, but the roles often go to someone much younger who they can train up and who is potentially cheaper.”

Sharman was earning £50,000 for his corporate work 20 years ago. “Now I’m applying for roles with salaries of around £35,000. I accept that; it’s a different sector. But it’s demoralising when you battle to get people to take the time to look at your experience and what you’ve done in your career, and are just ignored.”

Indeed, when workers aged over 50 are made redundant, they are statistically less likely to return to work within three months than those under 50, Labour Force Survey statistics show.

Jackie Brown, a mechanical engineer, is one such older worker struggling to break back into the industry that she left in October 2023 to care for her husband.

Brown had come to her work later in life: after a career in the civil service, she graduated in engineering aged 32, and then spent two decades working for industry giants including Rolls-Royce, GKN and BAE Systems. But after she left her senior engineering role on BAE’s submarine division two years ago, the 64-year-old said: “I’ve really struggled to find a permanent position.”

Brown, who is now working with Stem Returners, which helps people return to roles in the science, technology and engineering sectors, said that subcontractor roles cropped up. “Companies want my experience for a brief time, but when it comes to a new permanent role, they’re not keen to invest in people my age,” she said.

“The government wants us to work till we drop, and I have a lot of skills and want to get back to engineering — my dream job would be to work on the sixth-generation jet that the UK is working on with Japan — but age seems to be a disadvantage. Firms don’t want to invest in training an older person.”

She added: “It’s a shame. I have a wealth of experience and, having been around a bit longer, I perhaps have more ‘people skills’ than some of the new graduates. When I worked through Covid on engineering defence projects, my work was classified as of national importance. Now it feels quite the opposite — like, as an older person, the industry thinks you should just retire. But I’m still quite capable. I just want to get back to work.”