Residents run legal fight against ‘monstrous’ Boomers complex proposal
LONDON: A disgruntled group of residents is funding a legal challenge to a proposed Boomers community development.
Neighbouring resident Caroline Janssen and community group Save Currumbin have applied to the Planning and Environment Court, seeking declarations that John Fuglsang Developments Pty Ltd’s applications at 776 Pacific Pde, Currumbin, were impact assessable, rather than code assessable.
They are also seeking orders the two approved, code assessable development applications for the former site of the Elephant Rock Cafe be set aside.
Save Currumbin claims the council has essentially approved a seven-storey building in an area that is zoned for a maximum of three storeys.
Proponent John Fuglsang Developments – directed by the millionaire Hobart businessman of the same name – has had a number of starts to get the project to this point.
Council said the first attempt at a development application for three units and a shop in December 2022 was not properly made after officers decided it was a four-storey development in a three-storey planning zone.
In April 2023 Mr Fuglsang’s company submitted amended plans for the development, changing its form and adding an apartment.
“It is important to note that the building is completely below the 15m height limit and does not exceed three storeys in a single vertical plane which is the primary issue raised,” material submitted to the council said.
The council agreed it was properly made and code assessable and approved it in February 2024.
There were four attempts at a change application lodged from March 2025 to add an additional apartment, all of which did “not address officers’ concerns … the development exceeds three storeys in height”.
A subsequent change application adding an additional apartment and altering the form of the project was lodged in November 2025 and approved in February 2026.
The approval prompted an angry community meeting in late February at the Currumbin Nippers Club, where it was claimed the five-unit project would be a blight on the picturesque and sensitive Currumbin Hill.
Save Currumbin director and retired real estate agent Patrick Dixon this week said that after rejecting the earlier applications, Gold Coast City Council “simply rolled over and permitted what is essentially a seven-storey building on the narrow Elephant Rock Cafe site”.
He said the council’s “backflip” on a “monstrous development” threatened the unique character of Currumbin Beach.
“This proposed building won’t personally affect the views from my residence, but I just cannot face the prospect of swimming between the flags for the next 30 years staring at this monstrosity, wishing I had done something about it,” he said.
The appeal argues that at the time the approved applications were made, a maximum building height of three storeys or 15m was designated under the relevant planning schemes, that the project exceeds that height, and that they therefore should have been impact assessable.
Impact assessable development applications require public consultation go before council for a vote.
Code assessable applications can be approved by council officers.
The appeal alleges the council in the circumstances could not be satisfied the original development application or the change application were code assessable.
Mr Fuglsang, who controversially closed the popular Elephant Rock Cafe and demolished it several years ago, has previously defended the project as “a wonderful outcome for the area”.
He said it would provide much needed extra housing.
The developer previously said the council would have “a major fight from me” if they tried to make the project impact assessable.
“I won’t accept it, and I won’t accept it laying down,” he said in 2025.
Mr Fuglsang declined to comment.
Gold Coast City Council said it was unable to comment on active court matters.
Both John Fuglsang Developments and GCCC are yet to file any material with the court.






