Row over who should control health system
LONDON: Private insurance funds already control some dental, optical and mental health clinics. Could hospitals be next.
If you live in a capital Australian city and need to see a dentist or optometrist, there is a good chance you will end up in a clinic owned by your private health insurer. The same could be true for hospitals in the near future.
Health funds such as Medibank Private, HCF, NIB and Bupa are investing hundreds of millions of dollars into primary care and telehealth. The move marks a significant shift in the healthcare model. Insurers have traditionally funded healthcare, but now they want to provide it as well.
The industry catchphrase for the model, more common in the United States, where insurers have an enlarged role in patient care is “vertical integration” – and doctors do not like it.
Global health fund Bupa, which competes with Medibank Private as Australia’s largest insurer, revealed this week it plans to open 130 integrated medical centres around the country in the next three years. It also intends to operate 60 mental health clinics by 2027.
Bupa is not alone. Other funds are pouring capital into medical clinics, telehealth and home care services as part of a move to have more control over what is known as the provision of “extras” for the 15 million Australians with private health insurance. This is for a range of services such as optical, dental, pathology and physiotherapy.
While there is upside for private health fund members who may avoid out-of-pocket fees if they are treated at a clinic owned by their insurer, healthcare professionals and hospital operators warn Australia is drifting towards a US-style system where health funds have too much say over patient care.
“We do have concerns about the purchasing of health services by insurers. We have clearly seen in the US models where insurers seek to manage the care of patients, which doesn’t deliver better health outcomes, and that is not the direction we want to be heading in here,” says Danielle McMullen, the president of peak doctors body, the Australian Medical Association.
“There is an inherent conflict of interest if you are providing a healthcare service, and you are also the insurer. We want to make sure patients and the doctors are the ones making decisions about the care they receive, not the insurer or the owner of the hospital, and we are not in a scenario where the system puts profit before patients.”
The sale of Healthscope, the country’s second-largest private hospital operator, has sparked a fresh debate about whether insurers should be allowed to provide clinical care, particularly if their reach extends to hospitals. Healthscope this week offered to cede control of its board to lenders who hope to find a new owner for its 38 hospitals.
Bupa had appointed advisers to look at a possible bid for Healthscope assets. It came as the insurer’s global chief executive Inaki Ereno, who was in Melbourne this week, said the insurer wanted up to 30 per cent of its claims to be handled by parts of the healthcare system it controlled.
“Bupa’s CEO has stated an aspiration to drive 25 to 30 per cent of its claims through its own ecosystem. For context, three-quarters of private health insurance claims relate to hospital costs,” Bank of America Merrill Lynch analyst Freya Kong tells clients.
“With private health insurers already integrating the provision of extras cover, ownership of hospitals seems to be a possible next step.”
It would not be the first time an insurer has owned a private hospital. In March, Medibank opened the 60-bed Adeney Private Hospital in Melbourne it owns as a joint venture with Amplar Health – a facility that doctors say is well run.
However, NIB was less keen to go down the same path and in 2006 sold its Newcastle Private Hospital to Healthscope.
“I’m not a big fan of vertical integration,” NIB’s former chief executive Mark Fitzgibbon says, arguing there is a conflict between providers looking to maximise patient and treatment volumes to make more money and insurers who want to minimise volumes so they have to pay less benefits for members.
Unlike the US, where about 80 per cent of doctors work for corporations, he says Australian clinicians refuse to be bossed around. “We just don’t have that culture in Australia. Managing clinicians can be a challenge. They are very independently minded and see themselves as sole operatives.”
Analysts argue innovative insurers will breathe life back into the health system because they will be better managers of costs and inefficiencies, but concede this will be accompanied by concerns around clinical autonomy.
Ereno says insurers want more control over the system because it will enable them to better manage costs. Investing in clinics also means insurers can attract new members with the offer of no-gap treatments for basic services such as a teeth cleaning, and by upselling other services.
The so-called vertical integration model has existed for years. In Australia, Bupa owns 170 dental clinics, 49 optical and hearing stores and 22 medical centres. Medibank has a different model via partnerships with clinics, day surgeries and home care through joint ventures that it controls.
Rather than owning clinics, NIB partners with third-party providers who operate more than 300 dental practices under the insurer’s brand through naming rights agreements.
Insurer-owned services get mixed reviews. Some health fund members said their families had been to insurer-operated dental clinics for years and were happy with the result, particularly the low cost. Others were less complimentary.
“It was crap. The appointment was super short but 70 per cent of the time was spent trying to upsell me something: tooth whitening, an X-ray I didn’t need,” Helen from Melbourne says of her check-up at an insurer-branded dental clinic.
Private hospital operators are the biggest critics of insurers controlling the system. Catholic Health Australia, which represents 63 private hospitals, wants the federal government to set out clear guidelines for health system ownership.
“Under managed care, health insurers hold significant control over treatment decisions, requiring individuals to use providers within the network, therefore increasing profits for the insurer while reducing choice and control for the consumer,” it argues in a position paper.
Brett Heffernan, the chief executive of the Australian Private Hospitals Association, whose members include Ramsay Health Care, is more blunt.
“It is a ploy to weasel into clinical decision-making,” he says. “The only people who should be making decisions about what care a patient receives and where that care is delivered is the doctor and their patient.”
However, health insurers argue there is no risk of Australia adopting the US model because there are laws in place forcing health funds to pay benefits regardless of where a member is treated.
“There are also penalties for directing doctors and other health professionals to act against their patients’ best interests and pre-authorisation of treatment by health funds is not permitted,” says Rachel David, the chief executive of Private Healthcare Australia, which represents health insurers.






