Senior living operating environment at ‘critical juncture’ as 2025 begins

LONDON: “The senior living industry is at a critical juncture” as 2025 begins, National Investment Center for Seniors Housing & Care President and CEO Ray Braun said.

“While we are seeing strong operating fundamentals — like rising occupancy rates and robust consumer demand — growth will not follow a straight line,” he predicted. “Operators must navigate supply-demand imbalances, higher construction costs, changing consumer preferences and affordability pressures. As we respond to demographic growth, we must remain attuned to what consumers are willing and able to pay, ensuring we strike the right balance between quality and cost.”

Braun is one of several leaders of organizations serving the industry who were consulted for insights into potential challenges that will face providers in the new year.

Another, Arick Morton of NIC MAP Vision, also used the word critical to describe the 2025 senior living operating environment, saying that it will “reflect a critical inflection point.”

“While occupancy and absorption rates are already surging — up 40% year-over-year in 2024 — supply growth remains historically low, creating a tightening market,” Morton said. “Operators who adopt data-driven strategies will be best positioned to capitalize on these conditions.”

2025 follows a year in which capital market conditions were the top challenge facing owners and operators, Braun said. An improvement in those conditions will be needed if the industry is to meet increasing demand.

“While we saw modest improvement in the second half of the year, access to debt capital — particularly for new construction loans — remains significantly constrained,” he said. “This limited financing has delayed refinancings, stalled development projects and limited growth across the industry.”

The capital markets will continue to remain a challenge for many owners and operators in 2025, American Seniors Housing Association President and CEO David Schless predicted. A focus of ASHA’s State of Seniors Housing research, he added, will be to “help owners and operators, lenders and investors, and other professionals better understand the performance metrics of our business.”

The association has invested “considerable resources” with HealthTrust over the past couple of years to update the research effort by adding a state-of-the-art data platform, he said.

“Going forward, we expect to collect and report on financial and operational performance data for the full spectrum of seniors housing product types in a timelier fashion,” Schless said. “Additionally, we expect that by 2026, the SOSH data will be more robust than ever and available as an online industry resource with far greater analytical options than ever before.”

Opportunities still exist for companies to improve their financial performance, even after recently experiencing improvements, he said.

“I believe the industry will continue to focus its energies on leasing vacant units, reducing discounts, and improving overall efficiency and margins,” Schless said.

A variety of issues

Meanwhile, lenders are continuing to “work through a variety of issues across various real estate sectors,” Schless noted.

“Agency financing (Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac) remains markedly lower than it has been historically due to the impact of COVID,” he said, noting that the association plans to encourage the Federal Housing Finance Agency to “take measures in 2025 to allocate a higher portion of the overall lending cap for seniors housing to bring liquidity back to pre-pandemic levels.”

Senior living companies will continue to face such issues this year, Braun said, pointing out that more than $10 billion in senior living loans will mature in 2025.

“These loans were largely originated during a period of meaningfully lower borrowing costs,” he said. “Borrowers will need to adjust capital structures to reflect interest rates in 2025.”

And although the industry has seen progress in restoring net operating income margins, Braun said, cost pressures have been persistent, tempering gains.

“Over the past few years, rising expenses for goods, utilities, insurance and staffing had a cumulative impact on operators’ margins,” he said. “While there is progress, expense inflation remains a challenge for operating profitability.”

A strategic approach to growth

Providers have had to take a strategic approach to growth, Morton said, noting that in 2024 they faced “a confluence of challenges, such as high construction costs, elevated interest rates and a dislocated capital market, which made securing financing and completing projects difficult.

In 2025, he predicted, “demand will begin to significantly outstrip supply due to the rapid growth of the 80+ population.” This demographic shift, Morton added, “presents both challenges and opportunities.”

To take advantage of the opportunities, he said, “operators must transition from a ‘survive at all costs’ mindset that was adopted to survive the pandemic.” Instead, Morton said, operators “must optimize their portfolio through strategic expansions, renovations and pricing strategies, as NIC MAP Vision data shows the need to triple current senior housing development rates to meet demand by 2030.”

The demographic shift that has begun will define the senior living industry for the next two decades, he said, and NIC MAP Vision’s data platform can help operators pinpoint opportunities for development and expansion, Morton said.

With baby boomers turning 61 to 79 in 2025, the oldest among them already are a few years into the age range when most people who move into senior housing do so: 79 to 84, according to ASHA’s Where You Live Matters website for consumers. The average age of a senior living resident is 84, according to the site.

“While the growing 80+ population offers a generational opportunity, the industry must act swiftly to address the looming supply gap,” Morton warned. “Current development rates meet only 25% of the necessary pace to sustain demand, highlighting an urgent need for collaboration and investment.”

An evolving population

Investors will want to be prepared for the evolving resident population to which Braun alluded, and senior living communities will need to evolve with them.

“I believe a foreseeable challenge facing assisted living will be managing the growing needs of a population that is entering assisted living with more chronic conditions,” National Center for Assisted Living Executive Director LaShuan Bethea said. “This means that assisted living communities must adapt to help residents manage these chronic conditions effectively.”

As older adults continue to age, they increasingly are focusing on health and wellness to maintain their independence, she said.

“Population health management will be essential in helping seniors stay healthy and also enabling providers to offer more personalized and preventative care for seniors who require assisted living services,” said Bethea, who previously has said that value-based care is another way to look at population health management. “Additionally, integrating technology, such as wearables, can play an important role in helping providers monitor chronic conditions while helping residents remain independent and minimize the likelihood of health decline.”

New administration

In the meantime, with control of the executive branch of the federal government, as well as both parts of the legislative branch, soon to be under members of the Republican party, marking a switch from 2024 to 2025 for the presidency and Senate, Braun said that NIC will be watching.

“There is uncertainty about the economic impact of many of the incoming administration’s proposed policies,” he said. “Senior living owners and operators in 2025 will need to navigate the potential impacts of increased tariffs and changes in immigration and healthcare policy. Owners and operators will need to plan their path forward for 2025, but be nimble and pivot if needed as the year unfolds.”

NIC also is closely monitoring the Federal Reserve’s monetary policy, Braun said.

“While the Fed operates independently, administration policies and macroeconomic conditions — like labor markets and inflation — influence their decisions,” he said. “Rate actions by the Fed will have far-reaching implications for borrowing costs, capital markets and, ultimately, the financial health of senior living providers.”

Morton said that NIC MAP will be watching for policy changes that affect interest rates.

“High interest rates have already suppressed construction starts to near-record lows, and further disruptions could exacerbate the supply gap,” he said. “NIC MAP Vision data underscores the need for bipartisan recognition of the critical investment gap in senior housing. Our data estimates that more than $1 trillion in new inventory is required by 2041 to meet demand. Advocacy for stable funding mechanisms will be essential for the sector’s continued growth.”

Argenum President and CEO James Balda said that the association will be keeping an eye on tax reform.

“Tax reform presents enormous opportunities to advance meaningful policies to help more Americans plan and save for their long-term care needs; HSAs, FSAs, 529s, life insurance alternatives — lots of options are on the table, and we are finally seeing more lawmakers interested in putting ideas into action,” he said. “Our job is to make sure that any proposal will be available for Americans to choose assisted living for their care.”

Schless said that tax reform is an area of interest to ASHA as well. The topic “will figure prominently” on the GOP agenda in 2025 given that provisions of the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act expire this year, he said.

“It is too early to make predictions about the scope of such legislation, but ASHA will be very engaged to ensure that favorable tax treatment gained in 2017, such as the passthrough provisions and the business interest deduction, are not lost,” Schless said. “We will also seek specific senior living tax credits and programs.”

Balda said that Argentum also will be watching for tariff-related efforts undertaken by the federal government, adding, “We are closely watching the potential impacts of tariffs and further tightening of the labor market through proposed deportations that could lead to further inflationary pressures for our communities and residents.”

The Argentum CEO also said he expects the scrutiny seen in 2024 of the role of private investment in healthcare and assisted living to continue as well, although he said that the attention has “provided tremendous opportunities to help educate policymakers on who we are and how we are different.”

Schless said ASHA will be monitoring that situation, too.

“The Republican majority is less likely to engage on such matters, but it will be important to influence any legislation introduced by presenting facts and data to support our contention that assisted living should be excluded from the broader healthcare/private equity/real estate investment trust debate,” he said.

ASHA, Schless said, will continue to participate in the Congressional Long Term Care Caucus to ensure that topics that are a priority for the industry, such as the need for all capital sources to be available for investment in senior living, “are on the radar of Congress.”

Additional priority areas for the industry, he said, include workforce shortages, long-term care financing, Medicaid home- and community-based services, and the need to promote the benefits of senior living to policymakers and consumers.

LeadingAge President and CEO Katie Smith Sloan said that actions on affordable housing and Medicare Advantage issues are some of what the association will be watching for.

“For affordable housing, in addition to workforce constraints and resident mental health challenges, it’s the historic and chronic lack of sufficient resources to preserve, expand and improve affordable homes that keeps providers up at night,” she said.

LeadingAge, Sloan said, will work “to protect and expand federal rental assistance programs, including strong funding levels for housing programs at the Department of Housing and Urban Development and United States Department of Agriculture, improvements to the Low Income Housing Tax Credit, and protections for older adult renter households.”

Another type of financing

Sloan also noted that another type of financing, Medicaid financing, as well as Medicare Advantage figure into the association’s plans for 2025.

“Medicaid has been noted by congressional leadership as ripe for reform to offset other spending priorities,” she said. “Any changes to Medicaid financing or eligibility would leave massive budget holes for states to fill and destabilize insurance coverage for millions of Americans, further imperiling the healthcare workforce and the health of our country.”

Regarding Medicare Advantage, she said that LeadingAge has seen “a lot of cheerleading” for it among Republicans. “However, we understand from our members that it is time for new guardrails in this program.”

The association, Sloan said, is advocating for improvements to address “problematic behaviors” with the plans, including the use of prior authorization-driven care denials to limit service provision and curb costs, actions that the CEO said “enable them to profit at the expense of older adults and the providers who seek to care for them.

“This cannot continue,” she added. “Change is needed to ensure healthcare access and fair compensation for providers, and to also protect federal Medicare funding overall.”