Seniors housing performance data carries more weight than brand

LOS ANGELES: Senior housing operators looking to attract capital may gain more by proving how their properties perform than by building a nationally recognized brand. For investors, the distinction puts greater weight on local execution, reliable operating data and the cost of reaching prospective residents.

That was a central theme of a panel at the NIC Fall Conference in Chicago, where executives discussed what senior housing can learn from the hotel industry—and where the two businesses differ. A familiar name can bring customers through the door, they said, but service keeps them there, and performance data increasingly determines access to capital.

“You had to have a brand attached to your product to get loans because the lenders found it to be more dependable,” said John Arabia, founder and CEO of Taylor Vance LLC, describing the hotel industry in the 1990s. “Today, data drives access to capital.”

Local Reputation Matters More Than A National Name

For senior housing, the relationship between a community and its residents matters more than the name of the company behind it, according to Richard J. Hutchinson, CEO of Discovery Senior Living.

Discovery operates more senior housing units than any other operator in the United States, with more than 46,600 units across 418 properties as of June 1. Yet its corporate identity may not resonate with prospective residents.

“People know our properties based on the whites of the eyes of the people who run them, not by the brand name,” Hutchinson said.

“In fact, the ‘Discovery’ brand name isn’t very helpful in some cases—it’s more about the name of the building, which is named for the local market’s characteristics.”

Jack Callison, CEO of Sunrise Senior Living, described a brand as a promise that operators must fulfill through service.

“It’s the thing that your customers can count on,” he said. “A brand might bring them through the front door, but services are the key factor that keeps them.”

Performance Data Strengthens The Investment Case

As operators work to deliver on that promise, better data can help them measure results and make their case to capital providers.

Dave Johnson, co-founder and managing partner of Horizon Capital, pointed to the hotel industry’s advances in tracking demand, pricing and market share.

“I can determine my market share daily, not on a monthly basis. Revenue management helps us drive revenue,” he said.

That information gives hotel operators greater flexibility to adjust rates. Johnson said the same room might command $100 or $300 a night depending on demand—a more informed approach than calling a neighboring property to find out whether it was sold out before setting a rate.

Discovery has also made data central to its operations.

“We dump all of our data into an agnostic funnel, and it’s analyzed automatically,” Hutchinson said.

Consistent Reporting Would Make Comparisons Easier

Collecting data, however, is only part of the challenge. Consistent reporting also matters when investors and operators need to compare properties.

Johnson pointed to the hotel industry’s use of STR (formerly Smith Travel Research), established in the 1980s, which collects pricing data from hotels.

“I can now get forward-looking information about what’s going to happen in the market,” he said.

He also emphasized the importance of a uniform accounting system, allowing users to analyze a market even when its properties serve very different customer segments.

Arabia urged seniors housing executives to help develop common performance-tracking standards. The goal is to make operating results easier to compare across the sector.

Customer Acquisition Costs Deserve Closer Scrutiny

The discussion also turned to how operators reach customers and how much revenue they surrender along the way.

Arabia cautioned against allowing intermediaries to “get between you and your customer,” citing Expedia in hospitality and A Place for Mom in seniors housing.

“We are funding our own worst enemy if 18% of our profit on a 25% margin industry goes to companies like [seniors housing listing service] A Place for Mom,” he said.

His warning added another dimension to the branding discussion: recognition alone does not settle the economics of attracting residents. Alongside service and operating performance, investors should pay attention to the cost of securing that customer relationship.