Sibling inheritance battles surge as Baby Boomers transfer trillions

LONDON: Brothers and sisters at war is becoming increasingly common as trillions of dollars of wealth gets transferred from Baby Boomers to younger generations.

It lifts sibling rivalry to new levels as surging superannuation balances and property values multiply the sizes of inheritances, and the “bank of mum and dad” finds itself in painful situations when parents assist some children and not others.

Walker Pender Lawyers director Hayder Shkara said disputes between adult children over estates were rising.

“With an increase of blended families and families becoming more estranged, it results in situations where one child feels left out or feels like they are owed more from an estate,” Mr Shkara said.

“Often, inheritances are more than just about money. Normally there is a case of one child feeling like they sacrificed more, cared more, or received less than a sibling.”

As parents increasingly help their children with home deposits, education expenses and other financial assistance, tension between siblings can boil over.

“If parents are helping one child more than another during life, they should make a conscious decision about whether that support is intended to be an advance, a loan, a gift, or something to be taken into account later in the will,” Mr Shkara said.

“If they do not make that clear, the children will often write their own version of the truth after the funeral.”

Financial adviser Helen Baker said many siblings felt a sense of injustice when wealth was not shared equally.

“Tricky ones are often where, without advice, people set up their wills so it goes to the grandkids, and then if somebody has one grandchild and the other has two, should that be split three ways or is it 50-50?” she said.

Ms Baker said communication was vital. “Be upfront about it – some things that happen are maybe a little hidden and then get found out about later,” she said.

“If you can, be transparent about it and provide an understanding about the rationale behind it.

“Often when it’s misunderstood, or there’s no chance to understand, that’s when the friction can come into play, so communication is key.”

Even estranged children can have a claim to their parents’ estate under family provision laws, but experts say there are ways for parents to have more say in where their wealth goes.

“Estranged kids are still kids and they are entitled,” Ms Baker said.

“It’s very common – there’s a lot of families with those issues.

“A lot of times the lawyers will allocate an amount for them, probably nowhere near like what the others are getting, but it’s something. They then do a statutory declaration that documents why.”

If one child was estranged and bad with money, parents might allocate an amount to a trust that was managed by someone else “so they can’t blow it”, Ms Baker said.

While wills could be challenged, binding death benefit nominations made within superannuation were “pretty much unchallengeable”, she said.

“So if you only want to give to two kids rather than three, you can do that through super and there’s really not much they can do. They can still challenge the will where the house is, but super is where a lot of big money is these days and that’s a way to control it.

“There are ways to do what you want to do, but you’ve got to plan for it.”

Tiyce & Lawyers principal Michael Tiyce said disputes would most likely increase further as Australia’s economic environment became harsher.

Mr Tiyce said if there was a likelihood that children might challenge a will, parents should seek financial, tax and legal advice and consider giving gifts of cash or property during their lifetime rather than after they have died.

“If you know your testamentary decisions will be unpopular, such as cutting a child out of your will, then consider drafting a document that clearly sets out the reasons why, called a section 100 document,” he said.

“Challenging a will is an expensive proposition – the aim will be to try to have your affairs wrapped up as tightly as possible,” he said.

Armstrong Legal managing associate James Daly said skyrocketing real estate values were a key catalyst for the rising number of fights over family inheritances.

“A family home purchased for a modest sum decades ago can be worth millions, making the stakes high enough to justify legal action,” Mr Daly said.

“Also, cost-of-living pressures and ‘inheritance impatience’ mean many adult children view their parents’ estate as their only viable path to financial security or home ownership.

“This tension is often exacerbated by complex modern family dynamics, such as blended families or stepchildren, where competing interests naturally clash.”

Mr Daly said legal rules around children’s entitlements were governed by family provision laws.

“In Australia, while you have the freedom to choose your beneficiaries, you also have a moral duty to provide for the proper maintenance and support of your children, including, in some states, your adult stepchildren,” he said.

“If an adult child, including an estranged one, can demonstrate they have been left without adequate provision for their needs, they may claim a larger share. The courts will examine the reasons for the rift – if the parent’s conduct was the cause, the child’s claim remains strong.

“However, if the estrangement was the child’s choice and persisted despite the parent’s efforts to reconcile, the court may uphold the original will.”

Mr Daly said a parent could include an equalisation clause in their will, acknowledging money given during their lifetime and instructing the executor to reduce a sibling’s final inheritance by the same amount to ensure equality.

He said parents should communicate the contents of their wills early, and document the reasoning for any unequal distribution in a separate statement of wishes, which explained their perspective to the court.

“Avoid appointing feuding siblings as co-executors – instead, choose an independent third party or a professional executor to handle the estate neutrally,” he said.

Mr Shkara said gifts and loans to children should be documented, and a parent’s chosen executor should have a good relationship with all of the beneficiaries.

“Tell your executor about your estate plan and where you are keeping your estate documents,” he said.

“I recall a case where we thought there was no will, the beneficiaries all fought one another over the estate, and then once the house was sold the will reappeared sticky-taped to the back of a closet. Don’t make that mistake.”

There have been plenty of big court cases involving warring siblings.

Mr Shkara noted Poletti and Jobes (2015), which involved an estate worth about $3.2m.

“The deceased father had excluded two of his daughters from his will, leaving the bulk of the estate to their brother,” he said.

“The father said he had not spoken to the daughters for roughly 20 years, following his divorce in which he believed they had sided with their mother.

“The daughters brought a family provision claim, arguing that the will failed to make adequate provision for them.”

The court found the estrangement was not solely the daughters’ fault and awarded them $390,000 each, much smaller than their brother’s final share, Mr Shkara said.

Other key cases had much higher stakes because billionaires had children to other women.

In 2015 Olivia Mead, the secret daughter of late Perth mining billionaire Michael Wright, was left $3m from an $800m estate and ended up being awarded $25m from her father’s estate. However, that was later slashed to $6.14m in 2017 by an appeals court.

More recently, Paula Hitchcock – daughter of late billionaire Richard Pratt – remains locked in an ongoing legal battle with her half-siblings as she seeks to claim more than the $57m she received from him.