What world can learn from European-style rental model

LONDON: Cities such as Vienna and Berlin have more protections for seniors tenants — but even that more equitable model is now under pressure

The difference between the rental model in the UK and those in continental Europe is clear from the prices people are asked to pay. According to a 2018 Knight Frank report, the average monthly rent in London was €28.20 per sq metre, the highest in Europe. In Vienna, the average price was just €9.40. In Berlin, it was €9.80. Even in Paris, the most expensive city outside the UK and Ireland, rental prices per sq metre were 36 per cent cheaper than London.

Many think the UK could solve its housing crisis by embracing a European-style rental model — which vary, but typically include greater protections for tenants, caps on rent rises and longer tenancies. The problem is, even cities renowned for equitable rentals are struggling with demand and an influx of international investors.

If the UK is to strike the right balance, what lessons can be learnt?

“Our philosophy is the highest quality of living for everyone,” says Wolfgang Müller, deputy municipal director of the City of Vienna. Some 60 per cent of homes in Vienna are social housing, with the city owning 24 per cent, and the remainder by co-operatives — companies subsidised to build homes with non-profit reduced rents.

The system dates back to the period just after the first world war, when Austria’s Social Democratic Workers’ party came to power in Vienna. It believed the city should become an intellectual stimulant for the proletariat, and began a programme of Wohnkultur (dwelling culture). They built Gemeindebauten — superblocks of city-owned rental apartments with distinguished names (George-Washington-Hof, Goethe-Hof), some more than a kilometre long. During the civil war of 1934, the Gemeindebauten were often battlegrounds. The coral-coloured Karl-Marx-Hof still bears the bullet holes.

Utilitarian housing blocks may not appeal to everyone, but many subsidised homes in Vienna are architecturally ambitious. The Alt-Erlaa complex, built in the 1970s, has a motto “living like the rich”, and features a series of rooftop pools. The Gasometer City district includes a vast, glass-domed plaza by Jean Nouvel. The 40-unit city-subsidised Wohnprojekt Wien, completed in 2013, is a self-governing sustainable community that shares kitchens, cars, and a music room. Monthly rents are €10 per sq metre. The buildings are a long way from the UK’s “sink estates” that in 2016, then prime minister David Cameron vowed to bulldoze.

By 2020, there will be a further 4,000 city-owned and 10,000 co-operative units in Vienna. As of November, by law, two-thirds of any large new developments must also be social housing.

The future is less certain in some other European cities. Berlin, often regarded as the pinnacle of stable, low-cost renting, is facing difficulties. “The German law doesn’t work for the housing market we have now,” says Reiner Wild, head of the Berlin Tenants’ Association.

Net annual migration to Berlin is now between 40,000 to 50,000. “Supply cannot react as fast as the demand”, says Matti Schenk, senior research consultant at Savills Germany. In 2018, Berlin had a vacancy rate of 0.9 per cent according to the CBRE empirica index. Tenants at flat-viewings, “will be there with 30 or 40 people,” says Schenk.

Tenants in the German capital are well protected by rental laws — “It is almost impossible for a landlord to push you out,” says Schenk. The Mietpreisbremse or “rental brake”, introduced in 2015, limits rents for existing rental homes (new lettings are exempt) to prices set in the Berliner Mietspiegel index. If prices exceed it by more than 10 per cent, tenants can take landlords to court. The problem is, “lots of people ignore it”, says Christoph Michler, team leader of rentals at Ziegert, Knight Frank’s Berlin partner. Firstly, for apartments that conform to the Mietspiegel, “there is no real yield to be honest”, he says. And, if tenants are successful in court, landlords have no penalty but to reimburse the difference. “Many are willing to take the risk,” says Michler.

Other investors are oblivious. “From China we have a problem that they don’t know the rent laws in Germany,” says Wild. Foreign landlords often work to the laws of their own countries, he says. Between a quarter and a third of investors in Berlin’s buy-to-let market are international, estimates Michler.

Tinkering with rental laws can be controversial. In Paris, rental laws have changed in recent years.

In 2014, France introduced the ALUR, a law allowing tenants to contest rents 20 per cent above indexed rates. By August of 2016, some 30 per cent of residential leases in the city had come down in price. But in November 2017, Emmanuel Macron introduced the ELAN. Rent control became optional for municipalities and Paris revoked the caps. A July 2018 report by France’s National Association for Consumer and User Protection showed that in six months, Paris’s rate compliance had dropped from 61 per cent to 48 per cent.

Then in December, the Mayor of Paris, Anne Hidalgo, said she would reintroduce the caps, albeit under a system that tried to incorporate desirable aspects of a property — whether the home has a nice view, for example.

Social housing is also a focus of mayoral policy. Hidalgo aims to increase the proportion of social housing in Paris from 20 per cent to 30 per cent by 2030. The demand is high. The waiting list for social housing is 230,000, says Stéphane Dauphin, chief executive of Paris Habitat, the city’s social housing company.

Projects include the new Clichy-Batignolles eco-neighbourhood in the 17th arrondissement, where half of units are social and 20 per cent have controlled rent. Market rate units are pricey, though, at €40 per sq metre, says Alison Ashby, co-founder of estate agents Junot. “The real problem is for the middle class”, says Dauphin. “Sometimes it is impossible to stay in Paris”.

High rental costs are often blamed for squeezing out middle class tenants in London too. A 2018 report by the Centre for London found that, between mid-2016 and mid-2017, migration out of London was 14 per cent higher than the previous year.

The worst hit in London are the poorest. The lack of protection from an assured shorthold tenancy — the most common type of UK tenancy — means tenants can be easily evicted, says Chloé Serme-Morin, of FEANTSA, a European body that tackles homelessness.

“In the UK, the main driver of homelessness, before family breakdown, before individual circumstances, is the end of [a] shorthold tenancy.” Between 2009-10, the end of an AST was cited in 10 per cent of homeless cases in London, according to National Audit Office data. In 2016-17, it accounted for 39 per cent.

Could the European model work in London? The roots of the problem lie in a lack of investment, the privatisation of social housing and population growth, but most of all it is an attitude, says Serme-Morin. Housing today is seen as an investment rather than a right.